Also you might want to make a note that with scotland you're using the councils rather than the counties. granted politically councils serve the administrative positions of counties while the traditional scottish counties are more more for military concerns.
Some of the English ones aren't counties either, or the council area does not match the county area - Lancashire and Cheshire being good examples. The word 'County' is being phased out of local authorities as it has caused no end of confusion since the 1970s.
This quiz uses principal areas in Wales, council areas in Scotland, ceremonial counties in England, traditional counties in Northern Ireland and counties (traditional, as opposed to administrative) in Ireland
By my count there's three different concepts at play on this map. Picking one concept and sticking with it (admin, ceremonial, traditional) would make for a superior quiz.
I did pretty well on England (except Berkshire, which I swear I always forget), but I definitely need to brush up on the others. A fine quiz, though: I was hoping that the various county quizzes would be combined eventually.
A simple way to remember Berkshire: It's the obvious greatest county because I live there. It's also the only 'Royal' County and the only country to be named after a forest.
It looks as if I was half way through ordering the Irish counties and then just stopped to do something else and forgot to finish it before releasing the quiz back in March. Oh well. QM fixed it now - thanks!
I remembered mayo and kerry and kilkenny haha, they stood out to me when I was on holiday in ireland. (though english doesnt have kerry I think you call it currypowder, so it is less funny)
Enjoyed this quiz a lot :) Got all of England and Wales but need to work on my geography in the rest of Britain and Ireland (managed a few extra Scottish ones thanks to Gloryhammer though).
The Republic of Ireland is not a part of the British Isles. The term “British Isles” is insulting to the people of the Republic of Ireland. This is an old and outdated term used for the islands of Great Britain and Ireland. Out of respect for the Republic of Ireland, I suggest you remove ROI or change the title.
There are alternative terms that are less insulting that can be used. The Irish do not use this term as it is insulting to many Irish, as this term was created when under British rule. It’s associated with the British Empire. It may be a geographical term, and not political, but Irish do not use it as it comes with a long history. There is a Wikipedia page about the dispute over this name, suggesting more neutral terms that are not offensive to the Irish people.
This is a good quiz, but please, I really would suggest using a different term. It’s not fair on the many Irish who are insulted by this term.
@Purplr The fact is that the British Isles is still used as a collective term for Great Britain and Ireland (and surrounding British and Irish islands), just as the Irish Sea, South China Sea, Sea of Japan, Gulf of Mexico, Indian Ocean, are currently used terms to refer to geographical areas that do not necessarily lie wholly within a single country's territory. The phrase 'show some respect' has nothing to do with the fact that the British Isles is the correct term for this geographical region.
No, it isn’t used as a collective term for two islands. There are over 3000 islands in the archipelago called the British Isles. Great Britain and Ireland are simply the largest two of these. They aren’t named after the British Empire, the name Britain is from ‘’Britannia’ which gradually shifted from ‘Pretannia’ which is a Romanisation of the CELTIC language names for the archipelago, since the Britons, Hiberni and Picts were the three main Celtic peoples the Romans and Greeks encountered when they first came to the islands, centuries before the actual colonisation into the Roman Empire and more than two millennia before the peak of the British Empire (1919). If the names ‘British’ ‘Britain’ offend you, you’ll need to take that up with the Celts that came up with it.
After reading into the situation more thoroughly, it seems the term can be perceived as derogatory by nationalists. I'd like to mention that I did confer with Irish friends of mine, all of whom said that the term is acceptable here.
Despite the fact the term is clearly used as exclusively geographic in this quiz, and not suggesting that Ireland is claimed by the UK in any way whatsoever, I have decided to include "Ireland" in the title of this quiz now, simply to appease both sides. The quiz will continue to use the accurate geographical term of "British Isles", but also include Ireland separately to stop this debacle.
It turns out when people post several long comments on your quiz complaining so vibrantly, most creators are bound to succumb to the stress of it at some point.
I hope this appeases your concerns, and I'm sorry if the term caused you distress, this was obviously not the intention of the quiz
Thoughts on whether we should allow the creator of a quiz to delete comments on their own quizzes? I am leaning towards yes. I would have deleted these comments myself (especially since these users haven't made other non-inflammatory comments on the site) except that you are an experienced quizmaker and can deal with it.
Perhaps instead of being deleted, simply being hidden? Similar to how reddit handles it, where the commenter can see their comment and doesn't know the difference, but everybody else doesn't see the comment at all.
Another alternative would be to allow comments to be collapsed by the quizmaker, that way comments are there to be read, but are slim and collapsed by default as to not clog the comments up.
I don't think silencing people's opinion is necessarily a good thing, however comments here were beginning to be uncivilised and direct attacks. As you say, I and others can and have dealt with it many times before, but simply deleting them entirely I think would cause problems.
Personally I think collapsing them could be a good approach, similar to how other websites deal with downvoted comments.
Saying 'The British Isles and Ireland' would be like saying 'The Indian Ocean and the Maldives' or 'The Malay Peninsula and Southern Thailand' - it's redundant, whether one takes offence by it due to historical/(geo)political reasons or not.
You can't get around it, 'British' is a loaded term, since whatever else it may be used for it is used as the nationality of the UK. I find it hard to accept that anyone would feel insulted by the circumlocution adopted by this quiz. But, please let's not get upset in these ways. Any moment now some people will be saying it's unacceptable to call the continent of Europe Europe because 'Europe' is a political construct of the EU.
Actually it's the other way round. "York" gets you North Yorkshire (though not South, East, or West Yorkshire), while you need to type in North Ayr, South Ayr, and East Ayr separately.
Thank you for making this. GRRRRR I am so annoyed, we have "social distancing" in this country at the moment, ok I nipped out to get some food, I encountered a dog walker who had trespassed on our land. i attempted to relate to her the experience I had had with an extremely nasty man who lives locally but brings his dog to our land so that it can have a crap. She informed me that we could not talk to each other because of yes social distancing my word. So that is Britain right now
I am so ignorant! At least I got all of England...
I don't know if it's my imagination but do they keep changing things in Wales. I thought there was no Merionethshire because that was too old, but then I put in Dyfed and that also wasn't on. Can't keep up.
It is noticeable that only "Cardiff" and "Swansea" which were both parts of Glamorgan originally are the only two Welsh "counties" that scored a higher percentage than Staffordshire which is the lowest scoring English county.
Finally Conquered this quiz. It has been 2 months since I started learning Counties, started with England, then Scotland, Wales and Ireland. After getting 100 pc on all individual quizzes, now I finally did this one! thanks for this quiz
Minor detail- The Isle of Arran in Scotland is part of North Ayrshire and not Argyll and Bute as is shown on the map for this quiz. North Ayrshire is often referred to as 'North Ayrshire and Arran' although I am not sure whether this is the official name of the council area or not.
The Isle of Arran is in North Ayrshire Council not in Argyll and Bute. Living here I must admit that this makes no sense as it is an island but this is the way things are.
By my count there's three different concepts at play on this map. Picking one concept and sticking with it (admin, ceremonial, traditional) would make for a superior quiz.
This is a good quiz, but please, I really would suggest using a different term. It’s not fair on the many Irish who are insulted by this term.
After reading into the situation more thoroughly, it seems the term can be perceived as derogatory by nationalists. I'd like to mention that I did confer with Irish friends of mine, all of whom said that the term is acceptable here.
Despite the fact the term is clearly used as exclusively geographic in this quiz, and not suggesting that Ireland is claimed by the UK in any way whatsoever, I have decided to include "Ireland" in the title of this quiz now, simply to appease both sides. The quiz will continue to use the accurate geographical term of "British Isles", but also include Ireland separately to stop this debacle.
It turns out when people post several long comments on your quiz complaining so vibrantly, most creators are bound to succumb to the stress of it at some point.
I hope this appeases your concerns, and I'm sorry if the term caused you distress, this was obviously not the intention of the quiz
Another alternative would be to allow comments to be collapsed by the quizmaker, that way comments are there to be read, but are slim and collapsed by default as to not clog the comments up.
I don't think silencing people's opinion is necessarily a good thing, however comments here were beginning to be uncivilised and direct attacks. As you say, I and others can and have dealt with it many times before, but simply deleting them entirely I think would cause problems.
Personally I think collapsing them could be a good approach, similar to how other websites deal with downvoted comments.
Bit odd that in Scotland I can type n ayr for North Ayrshire, but in England I need north york for North Yorkshire.
Great quiz and good for learning!
I don't know if it's my imagination but do they keep changing things in Wales. I thought there was no Merionethshire because that was too old, but then I put in Dyfed and that also wasn't on. Can't keep up.
Great quiz btw, I love these kind of "fill the map" ones.
Minor detail- The Isle of Arran in Scotland is part of North Ayrshire and not Argyll and Bute as is shown on the map for this quiz. North Ayrshire is often referred to as 'North Ayrshire and Arran' although I am not sure whether this is the official name of the council area or not.