Additionally, these are entirely based off of critic reviews, not taking into account audience opinion.
I also see the list as very inept. I could potentially create a better version of this quiz, still using the subpar Rotten Tomatoes statistics, but taking into account audience approval and amount of reviewers instead of only using the statistics of a few hundred critics. I'm fairly positive a massive change would be seen, as movies such as Shawshank have over 250,000 ratings with a 98% approval rating.
On a different note, a realistic quiz of the "Top 100 Movies", in my opinion, is essentially impossible to create. You can always look at stats, like box office, critics reviews, and/or audience reviews but there are just too many different factors you have to take into account while looking at what the "greatest" movies are.
also, I do agree with you and all commenters that the list is somewhat weird. For comparison, the top 100 list from IMDB, while having its own downsides, feels much less weird, probably due to the huge base of voters.
And anyway "Black Panther" could not even make it in the top 20 list of MCU movies IMHO, let alone being #5 in this one.
Copyright H Brothers Inc, 2008–2022
Contact Us | Go To Top | View Mobile Site