It really is for all intents and purposes, I've been there and it takes like an hour to get from one end to the other, the only bit I wouldn't include in the figure is the urban areas in Gozo, Rabat and a few other areas in the north so it wouldn't be the whole population of Malta but the population is almost 500,000 anyway so that figure seems very reasonable to me
Most of the dots are a bit off. I used a script to fetch the location of each city off the google maps API then used that data to place them all on the map. Either the map is a bit off, or the google maps API didn't give me the right location.
There are 2 cities named Brest in Europe. The one on the tip of Bretagne and one on the border of Poland and Belarus, formerly known as Brest-Litovsk. The former isn't big enough to make it into the list though.
I hate when they merge the two. They are very much seperate cities for all intents and purposes. The only thing this would have going for it is that there's a metro connecting the two cities, but that still doesn't make it one city. Especially because The Hague is the seat of the government it would make more sense if it was separate
I'm guessing it's becuase they are geographically part of Africa, even though they are culturally European. Same with Russian cities in Siberia, which are culturally European but geographically in Asia, so they don't count.
Quizmaster contacted me about it. I have an updated dataset that I use for other quizzes, but I haven't gotten around to updating this quiz, since the map takes a lot of work. Once it's updated, quizmaster will feature it
Don't understand some of these. Massa has only 70k inhabitants. Lots of others have more. To be pedantic - Bournemouth is not a city and has only c190k pop - Plymouth has 230k+ - think you have amalgamated Portsmouth and Southampton, they are separate cities. I do like the quiz but needs a bit more accuracy.
This quiz considers urban areas. If you count people by city limits, you get a very unbalanced view, since city limits in western Europe tend to be small, as they don't include suburbs and adjacent cities. In eastern Europe, these are typically included in city limits, so cities limits tend to be much bigger even though there aren't more people living in the area. Counting by urban area fixes this problem, since it counts where people actually live close together
Massa is the largest city in an urban area stretching from Viareggio to Sarzana, which is why it's here
I have no idea how I got Bydgoszcz. Not as in, "I have no idea how I remembered it." No, as in, "I have never heard of it and cannot imagine what I typed to get it. Oh well, I'll take what I can get.
I only knew Linz because I had a Couch Surfing host there... I think the night before I got to Salzburg, actually. Seemed like a decent-sized college town.
Hey, very nice quiz! But I don't think that Koblenz is rightfully in there... The city has about 110k inhabitants, the area might have up to 220k, but I can't see 350k there...
Even if you might get the 350k people if you add the city of Koblenz and the Kreis Mayen-Koblenz (which is not (!) completely part of the urban area of Koblenz), you would need to do the same or all other cities in Germany. So why is Mainz missing, which has, when you add the Kreis Mainz a total of 430k? Why is Offenbach missing which would have 480k? etc. etc. It just doesn't make sense
I think there's a minor issue with the dots for Arnhem/Nijmegen and 's Hertogenbosch, in the Netherlands. I guessed both, but the one for 's Hertogenbosch stayed red and the one for Arnhem/Nijmegen showed the name of 's Hertogenbosch.
That aside, great quiz! I had just over half this time, would love to do better so I'll revisit for sure. :D
The quiz is urban area not city proper. If you are using urban area and the same source for your data as the quiz maker then you have a point that these are wrong but you are using Wiki and they are using citypopulation.de, eurostat and Wiki so that would account for the discrepancies between your data and theirs. You are only using one of the sources that they are.
I got 166 out of 246, not too bad for a 12 turning 13 year old American. The least guessed ones I got were all random Russian cities for some reason lol
There is no way Massa can figure in this list. It is a medium size in Tuscany with barely 70k inhabitants. There is no way a larger metropolitan area can be attributed to Massa, its province itself is under 200k. Either a mistake, or it is preposterous.
Putting them together as one urban area doesn't make sense. It's like saying Manchester and Liverpool are the same city; or New York and Philadelphia.
Massa is the largest city in an urban area stretching from Viareggio to Sarzana, which is why it's here
I think most quizes consider they are.
That aside, great quiz! I had just over half this time, would love to do better so I'll revisit for sure. :D
Bournemouth is 465k max, not 553k.
Northampton is 212k max, not 359k.
Brighton is 475k, that's if you include Hove, not 596k.
Kingston upon Hull is 260k, not 403k.
And they were just the smaller UK towns that didn't seem to ring true.
The above numbers are all from Wiki.
Blue - National Capital
Black - Everything else
Heilbronn: City Prop=127k; UArea=180k; UAgglo=333k
Würzburg: City Prop=124k; UArea=164k; UAgglo=196k
Turns out, I was wrong.