| Clue | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| The only one who actually plays | Darryl Strawberry | 90%
|
| Nerve tonic causes gigantism | Ken Griffey, Jr. | 89%
|
| Pitt the Elder... LORD PALMERSTON | Wade Boggs | 72%
|
| Kicked off team for not shaving sideburns | Don Mattingly | 71%
|
| Thinks he is a chicken, due to hypnonsis | Roger Clemens | 69%
|
| Rescues woman, pets, and furniture from a house fire | Jose Canseco | 68%
|
| Arrested by Springfield police | Steve Sax | 66%
|
| Disappears into the "Springfield Mystery Spot" | Ozzie Smith | 65%
|
| Gets radiation poisoning at the power plant | Mike Scioscia | 60%
|