It would appear the you have misspelled 'Abigail.' You see, you spelt it 'Abagail' which is incorrect according to the Red Dead Wiki and the in-game subtitles. I would appreciate it if you could fix this as soon as possible. Thanks, kind regards, sideburnboy1.
i didn't get the Bill clue because it seemed like it was a character that only appeared in rdr1. I don't know why I'm bothering to complain...