I have to disagree with the description for Roseanne Barr: her show may have been about a working class family in Ohio that was just getting by, but that doesn't make it lowbrow. "Married with Children" is lowbrow; so are lots of sitcoms that focus on rich people, such as "The Nanny." Nice quiz otherwise; the only one I missed was Carrot Top (too lowbrow).
Obviously, you can't have everyone in here... but it'd be great to have Bill Hicks in. Outside of America he's generally regarded as the best standup your country has ever produced. (Maybe him or Chris Rock anyway.)
He isn't generally regarded as the best comic the US has produced. _Some_ may think this, but I've never met one; makes it unlikely that this is some sort of general consensus. Don't get me wrong, I love Bill Hicks, own every DVD special he has. But there's no way he's even in my top 25 list of US stand up comedians.
Got halfway, and quit when I realized there was no clue for Bill Hicks, Louis C.K, Eddie Murphy, Richard Pryor, Sarah Silverman, etc. How Carrot Top warrants inclusion is beyond me.
Many on this list have passed away. Why update for that reason? It doesn't make them any less great. (I've never heard of Carrot Top, so can't say for him/her.)
And although you have the caveat explaining when it was current, it wouldn't be bad to update now considering how many more have unfortunately passed. After all, your clues include their dates.
Great list, but there are plenty of classy comedians not on he list, eg Danny Kaye, Jerry Lewis & Richard Pryor and too few women comedians on the list
And although you have the caveat explaining when it was current, it wouldn't be bad to update now considering how many more have unfortunately passed. After all, your clues include their dates.