| Position | Amount of Selections | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| WR | 6 | Mike Evans | 98%
|
| WR | 1 | Chris Godwin | 90%
|
| QB | 1 | Tom Brady | 90%
|
| QB | 2 | Baker Mayfield | 88%
|
| QB | 1 | Jameis Winston | 88%
|
| DT | 7 | Warren Sapp | 80%
|
| T | 4 | Tristan Wirfs | 71%
|
| LB | 11 | Derrick Brooks | 68%
|
| QB | 1 | Brad Johnson | 63%
|
| WR | 1 | Keyshawn Johnson | 61%
|
| CB | 5 | Ronde Barber | 61%
|
| RB | 2 | Doug Martin | 54%
|
| LB | 1 | Lavonte David | 54%
|
| DT | 2 | Vita Vea | 54%
|
| CB | 5 | John Lynch | 49%
|
| RB | 6 | Mike Alstott | 46%
|
| WR | 1 | Vincent Jackson | 46%
|
| RB | 2 | Warrick Dunn | 44%
|
| RB | 1 | Clifton Smith | 37%
|
| DE | 6 | Lee Roy Selmon | 37%
|
| DE | 1 | Jason Pierre-Paul | 34%
|
| C | 1 | Ryan Jensen | 34%
|
| LB | 2 | Shaquil Barrett | 34%
|
| DT | 6 | Gerald McCoy | 32%
|
| DE | 2 | Simeon Rice | 32%
|
| QB | 1 | Jeff Garcia | 29%
|
| CB | 1 | Darrelle Revis | 27%
|
| K | 1 | Martin Gramatica | 27%
|
| QB | 1 | Trent Dilfer | 24%
|
| G | 1 | Ali Marpet | 22%
|
| WR | 1 | Keenan McCardell | 22%
|
| RB | 1 | James Wilder | 20%
|
| LB | 2 | Hugh Green | 15%
|
| TE | 4 | Jimmie Giles | 15%
|
| LB | 1 | Kwon Alexander | 15%
|
| WR | 1 | Mark Carrier | 15%
|
| G | 1 | Logan Mankins | 10%
|
| LB | 1 | Dave Lewis | 7%
|
| TE | 1 | Dave Moore | 7%
|
| DT | 1 | Dave Pear | 7%
|
| T | 1 | Donald Penn | 7%
|
| LB | 5 | Hardy Nickerson | 7%
|
| LB | 1 | Shelton Quarles | 7%
|
| C | 3 | Tony Mayberry | 7%
|
| G | 2 | Davin Joseph | 5%
|
| CB | 1 | Donnie Abraham | 5%
|
| C | 1 | Jeff Christy | 5%
|
| P | 1 | Josh Bidwell | 5%
|
| G | 1 | Randall McDaniel | 5%
|
| CB | 1 | Wayne Haddix | 5%
|