| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| In "Family Matters" one of the brothers thinks Samuel is doing something wrong. Which brother is that? | Dean | 87%
|
| What is a skinwalker disguised as in "All Dogs Go to Heaven"? | A dog | 85%
|
| What is Dean turned into in "Live Free or Twihard"? | A Vampire | 82%
|
| Who is Dean living with in "Exile on Main Street"? | Lisa and Ben Braeden | 80%
|
| Who sends Sam and Dean to a world where they are Jensen Ackles and Jared Padalecki in "The French Mistake"? | Balthazar | 75%
|
| What did Balthazar do in "My Heart Will Go On"? | Unsink the Titanic | 73%
|
| Which of the actors directs "Weekend at Bobby's", making his directorial debut? | Jensen Ackles | 72%
|
| What kind of creature is kidnapping virgins in "Like a Virgin"? | Dragon | 70%
|
| What does Castiel become at the end of the season? | God | 68%
|
| Who does Eve bring back as a demon to torture the boys in "Mommy Dearest"? | Mary Winchester | 65%
|
| Whose job does Dean take over for 24 hours in "Appointment in Samarra"? | Death | 62%
|
| What is the monster in "Mannequin 3: The Reckoning"? | A ghost | 46%
|
| What is wrong with Sam most of the season? | He is soulless | 46%
|
| What does Castiel do to Lisa and Ben in "Let it Bleed"? | Wipes their memories | 44%
|
| What do Sam and Dean take care of in "Two and a Half Men"? | A baby | 42%
|
| Finish the quote: "Oh, well, that's great, 'cause without your power, you're basically just a _________________" | Baby in a trench coat | 38%
|
| Which two men fight about a case in "...And Then There Were None"? | Samuel and Bobby | 37%
|
| What are Sam and Dean dealing with in "Clap Your Hands if You Believe"? | Fairies | 35%
|
| Finish the quote: "This is a vessel. My true form is approximately the size of your _____________" | Chrysler Building | 31%
|
| Finish the quote: "Now I lay me down to sleep, I pray to Castiel to ___________________" | Get his feathery ass down here. | 24%
|
| What goddess is causing people to commit suicide in "You Can't Handle the Truth"? | Veritas | 23%
|
| Who does Castiel kill in the season finale? | Balthazar | 20%
|
| Finish the quote: "This is very complex. If the pizza man truly loves this babysitter _________________" | Why does he keep slapping her rear? | 20%
|
| Finish the quote: "Balthazar: Because that god-awful Celine Dion song made me _______________" | Wanna smite myself | 18%
|
| What is the name of the episode in which Castiel discovers porn and kisses a demon? | "Caged Heat" | 15%
|
| Who did Sam kill in flashbacks of a case a year before the events of "Unforgiven"? | A police officer | 4%
|
| What did Castiel tell Sam in "The Man Who Would be King"? | He rescued him from Lucifer's Cage | 4%
|
| Who does Castiel kill at the end of "Frontierland"? | Rachel | 3%
|
| What is killing police officers in "The Third Man"? | The Plagues of Egypt | 3%
|
| What happens to Sam in "The Man Who Knew Too Much"? | He goes crazy | 0%
|