| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Oldest Brother | Dean Winchester | 100%
|
| Youngest Brother | Sam Winchester | 100%
|
| Blonde Hunter and Daughter of ^ | Joanna Beth "Jo" Harvelle | 99%
|
| Brother's Father | John Winchester | 97%
|
| Hunter's Mentor | Bobby Singer | 96%
|
| Angel Searching for God (Wear's Trench Coat) | Castiel | 96%
|
| King of Hell | Crowley | 94%
|
| The First Fallen Angel | Lucifer | 94%
|
| Half Brother Met in Episode "Jump the Shark" | Adam Milligan | 89%
|
| Angel Also Referred to as "Trickster" and "Loki" | Gabriel | 89%
|
| Brother's Mother | Mary Winchester | 88%
|
| ^ His Girlfriend | Jessica Moore | 85%
|
| Blonde Demon Met In "The Magnificant Seven" | Ruby | 85%
|
| Oldest Most Powerful Archangel (^ His Brother) | Michael | 84%
|
| Roadhouse Owner and Mother of v | Ellen Harvelle | 77%
|
| Real Name of Carver Edlund the Supernatural Novel Writer in "The Monster at the End of This Book" | Chuck Shurley | 76%
|
| First Female Demon The Brother's Meet | Meg Masters | 76%
|
| Yellow Eyed Demon | Azazel | 73%
|
| Name of the Hunter who Made the Colt that Kills All | Samuel Colt | 72%
|
| Male Hunter with Mullet and Works at Roadhouse | Ash | 71%
|
| Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle (Angel) | Raphael | 71%
|
| Female "Thief" of Supernatural Items of Value | Bela Talbot | 69%
|
| The First Ever Demon Created | Lilith | 68%
|
| Angel who Fell from Grace | Anna Milton | 67%
|
| Male Demon Who Torture's Souls in Hell | Alastair | 52%
|
| Female Reaper's Name | Tessa | 45%
|
| Skilled Psychic Female | Pamela Barnes | 38%
|