So after five years I finally got around to updating this. Geez that was tedious. Mostly because I don't trust Box Office Mojo's assessment of genre.
Genre can be a pretty subjective thing. Most films exist in multiple genres simultaneously, and there will be arguments over which films belong in which genres as film genres are dynamic and amorphous.
I used my own well-informed, but subjective, opinions to classify all of these movies. And I made some subjective decisions about what to put where. For example, I decided that in the case of most comic book movies, which have increasingly come to dominate international box office, the genre of "comic book movie" pretty much always subsumes all others - so even though AntMan could theoretically be considered a heist movie, and Endgame a caper, and some could be horror, and most are action comedies, I'm filing the majority just under comic book.
There is one objective truth of genre: Star Wars is not Sci-Fi.
With the latest update I made the decision to, for most categories, disqualify both animated and foreign language films from consideration.
Animation because, while animated movies often do huge box office, most people don't think of "Cars" when they're thinking of "sports movies" - sort of the same way that comic book movies are subsumed by that label I feel animated films are usually subsumed by the fact that they are animated.
And foreign language because, even though it makes very little difference currently in any of the rankings ("Hi, Mom" could technically be counted as the top-grossing time travel movie ever made, and there's some film by Ang Lee that is now the highest grossing NC-17 movie of all time), with the explosion of the Chinese market the last few years, it seems all but inevitable that, fairly soon, the Chinese market will be more important than the American one. And I just don't know enough about Chinese movies to keep this up to date including them.
This took a considerable amount of research. It's possible I made mistakes. If you see any please point them out. Spirited discussion of what exactly defines a genre is also welcome, just know that in the case of a disagreement with the quiz maker you are wrong.
I keep fiddling with the design/format of this. I think it's pretty good now. Though I wish there was an easy way to do the categories where it was more clear and attractive when giving genres and sub-genres. There's probably some way to do the html coding for make the text left-aligned and right-aligned for example rather than all centered.
and now though I know QM and Stewart? have made huge upgrades to the quiz editor and it's probably much easier to make this quiz much prettier at this point in time... I'm too lazy/disinterested to take the time to learn how and implement these features. Hope it's not too ugly.
JP in concept and execution is pretty classic SciFi/Horror monster movie. Some mad scientist- or in this case well-meaning but a bit obsessed wealthy person with a team of scientists- decides to toy with nature or play God to create something. The inevitable result: scary things that smash, terrorize, and kill people. Think of Frankenstein.
Also, while I never personally found the film scary, I never find any film scary, and I know plenty of people who *did* think it was scary and I remember quite a few jumps and gasps in the movie theater watching it the first time.
Yes. This is badly in need of an update. But it takes a lot of research unlike some other quizzes. And I've had a lot on my plate lately. I even started doing the research once about 2 months ago and got about halfway through before I got distracted.
Gah! I went through the whole update and forgot to do this! But.. just went in and added it. Done! Pretty silly because I just watched that movie again last night while I was working on researching this update.
This quiz is awesome! As others have pointed out it could stand to be updated but otherwise, it's fantastic. I'm totally bewildered at some of the movies that made the cut though. (Wild Hogs of all things??)
I started doing the research to update it once, got half way through and got distracted. I'd like to keep this up-to-date but it's a bit more maintenance-intensive than any of my other quizzes. Glad you enjoyed it, though.
If not for my commitment to keeping the genres relatively "pure"... there are some movies that could be counted as "road movies" that grossed a lot more than Wild Hogs. Finding Nemo, for instance... basically follows the structure of a road movie. Though there are no roads in it.
There were many films eclipsed by their own sequels. The Avengers were overtaken by Endgame. Insurgent trumped Divergent. Jurassic Park was passed up by Jurassic World (though JP remains the top fiction adaptation and top sci-fi horror film; the sequels pretty well abandoned the horror genre). Hotel Transylvania was replaced by Hotel Transylvania 3.
Some other updates:
Bohemian Rhapsody replaced American Sniper as the top Biopic.
Furious 7 took the title of top Action Blockbuster from Dark of the Moon and top car chase movie from one of its own predecessors.
Bad Boys for Life topped Live Free or Die Hard as the top Shoot 'em Up and Lethal Weapon 3 as the top buddy cop movie.
The Lion King remake bypassed the Alice in Wonderland remake.
Warcraft took the title of top video game adaptation from Prince of Persia.
Mission Impossible - Fallout beat Sex and the City as top television adaptation.
Dunkirk became the top WW2 movie and top war movie beating out Saving Private Ryan and American Sniper, respectively.
Toy Story 3 was replaced by Jumanji 3 as top comedy because of the new rule about animation. But it was also eclipsed by Minions as the top animated comedy
How the Grinch Stole Xmas *would* have been replaced by, ironically enough, The Grinch, except for the same rule.
Beauty & the Beast (2017) replaced Frozen
Wolf Warrior 2 became the highest grossing foreign-language film beating The Intouchables (along with several other Chinese films) by a large margin.
Ne Zha (another Chinese film) beat Spirited Away to become the top foreign language animated film, but even in Japan Spirited Away has been usurped by some anime horror film about a demon train or something.
The Lion King (1993 and 2019 versions) became the top G and PG rated films, displacing Toy Story 3 and Frozen. And The Passion was defeated by Joker for the Rated R title.
Finally, the latest Halloween movie unseated Scream to become the top slasher film of all time, but Scream retains the title of top teen horror film as Jamie Lee has not been a teenager for quite some time.
Some previous mistakes were also corrected:
This is It has been the highest grossing documentary film for a while, beating Fahrenheit 911, if you look at international gross and not just US.
I originally replaced The Road to Perdition with Oblivion for top adaptation of a graphic novel, but upon further research found the graphic novel of Oblivion never actually existed; and then I decided that 300 should count in this category so gave the title to that film.
World War Z was previously credited as being the top zombie film when really it should have been I Am Legend - though there's some debate as to whether that's a true zombie film or not.
Terminator 2 previously held the title of top robot apocalypse movie. I had forgotten The Matrix.
But I created a new category for Sci-Fi/Time Travel so T2 could still retain the top spot somewhere. (also long ago decided that comic book movies were more fantasy than science fiction and so Endgame doesn't count here)
And... lastly... I came across the fact that Gravity (2003) took in 723 million at the box office, slightly more than Interstellar, but... I decided that floating around in low Earth orbit doesn't really count as "exploration"... so I left that category as it was. I don't remember if I found this before or not.
Already noticed a mistake after the update that I should have caught before... Home Alone should be counted as the highest-grossing Christmas comedy movie. For some reason I didn't consider it in that category but it made more than the live action Grinch. Somewhat amazingly, not as much as the more recent animated Grinch movie, but, with the new rule about counting animated films separately then Home Alone wins. Will fix with the next update I guess...
Note to self: also add type-ins for Wolf Warrior 2, Rocky IV, and Mary Poppins Returns without the sequel designations, to make them more consistent with the rest of the quiz.
Genre can be a pretty subjective thing. Most films exist in multiple genres simultaneously, and there will be arguments over which films belong in which genres as film genres are dynamic and amorphous.
I used my own well-informed, but subjective, opinions to classify all of these movies. And I made some subjective decisions about what to put where. For example, I decided that in the case of most comic book movies, which have increasingly come to dominate international box office, the genre of "comic book movie" pretty much always subsumes all others - so even though AntMan could theoretically be considered a heist movie, and Endgame a caper, and some could be horror, and most are action comedies, I'm filing the majority just under comic book.
There is one objective truth of genre: Star Wars is not Sci-Fi.
Animation because, while animated movies often do huge box office, most people don't think of "Cars" when they're thinking of "sports movies" - sort of the same way that comic book movies are subsumed by that label I feel animated films are usually subsumed by the fact that they are animated.
And foreign language because, even though it makes very little difference currently in any of the rankings ("Hi, Mom" could technically be counted as the top-grossing time travel movie ever made, and there's some film by Ang Lee that is now the highest grossing NC-17 movie of all time), with the explosion of the Chinese market the last few years, it seems all but inevitable that, fairly soon, the Chinese market will be more important than the American one. And I just don't know enough about Chinese movies to keep this up to date including them.
(I actually only tried lotr, so I don't know if you accept the whole title)
There were many films eclipsed by their own sequels. The Avengers were overtaken by Endgame. Insurgent trumped Divergent. Jurassic Park was passed up by Jurassic World (though JP remains the top fiction adaptation and top sci-fi horror film; the sequels pretty well abandoned the horror genre). Hotel Transylvania was replaced by Hotel Transylvania 3.
Some other updates:
Bohemian Rhapsody replaced American Sniper as the top Biopic.
Furious 7 took the title of top Action Blockbuster from Dark of the Moon and top car chase movie from one of its own predecessors.
Bad Boys for Life topped Live Free or Die Hard as the top Shoot 'em Up and Lethal Weapon 3 as the top buddy cop movie.
The Lion King remake bypassed the Alice in Wonderland remake.
Warcraft took the title of top video game adaptation from Prince of Persia.
Mission Impossible - Fallout beat Sex and the City as top television adaptation.
Dunkirk became the top WW2 movie and top war movie beating out Saving Private Ryan and American Sniper, respectively.
Toy Story 3 was replaced by Jumanji 3 as top comedy because of the new rule about animation. But it was also eclipsed by Minions as the top animated comedy
How the Grinch Stole Xmas *would* have been replaced by, ironically enough, The Grinch, except for the same rule.
Beauty & the Beast (2017) replaced Frozen
Wolf Warrior 2 became the highest grossing foreign-language film beating The Intouchables (along with several other Chinese films) by a large margin.
Ne Zha (another Chinese film) beat Spirited Away to become the top foreign language animated film, but even in Japan Spirited Away has been usurped by some anime horror film about a demon train or something.
The Lion King (1993 and 2019 versions) became the top G and PG rated films, displacing Toy Story 3 and Frozen. And The Passion was defeated by Joker for the Rated R title.
Some previous mistakes were also corrected:
This is It has been the highest grossing documentary film for a while, beating Fahrenheit 911, if you look at international gross and not just US.
I originally replaced The Road to Perdition with Oblivion for top adaptation of a graphic novel, but upon further research found the graphic novel of Oblivion never actually existed; and then I decided that 300 should count in this category so gave the title to that film.
World War Z was previously credited as being the top zombie film when really it should have been I Am Legend - though there's some debate as to whether that's a true zombie film or not.
Terminator 2 previously held the title of top robot apocalypse movie. I had forgotten The Matrix.
And... lastly... I came across the fact that Gravity (2003) took in 723 million at the box office, slightly more than Interstellar, but... I decided that floating around in low Earth orbit doesn't really count as "exploration"... so I left that category as it was. I don't remember if I found this before or not.