For the people that do not understand this map: The map is set to be modern day except for insets, which are in a time where Germany bordered a certain country
I agree with InuitSlim. Countries such as Norway, France etc were occupied but never incorporated into Germany. Wikipedia has a good map that might help: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German-occupied_Europe#/media/File:Europe_under_Nazi_domination.png Only the dark gray areas were really annexed.
Not really. It was basically just a French occupation zone from World War 1. France took control of the coal fields there in Versailles. In 1935, after a referendum generally considered fair (though it was after lots of campaigning by Germany), the Saar voted with over 90% to join Germany.
Good idea! The map(s) is/are a bit difficult to navigate. It might be better if the answer block for each time period was right next to the corresponding map to simplify things a little bit.
You forgot Neutral Moresnet, how dare you! ;-) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neutral_Moresnet
Further, the WW2 map is inconsistent on "what counts as Germany": occupied France (including Algeria?) is Germany but the occupied parts of the Balkans and Northern Africa are not?
Neutral Moresnet wasn't its own country, Algeria is "counted" but it doesn't border any other new countries, and about the German occupation of Yugoslavia borders it is now fixed.
It counts puppet states (they have a government thoroughly controlled by Germany), but not merely occupied territory (like the parts of the USSR that were occupied by German armies but never had a puppet government).
That's a stupid criteria. Germany had more control over directly occupied territory than e.g. somewhere like Denmark 1940-43, where a unity government made up of democratic parties continued to have significant control over internal affairs.
It seems weird to count puppet states but not occupied territory as part of the German Empire, since the latter was more directly under German control than the former.
I really like this quiz. However, one of the answer columns needs to be changed to "From 1920" rather than "From 1930" because that's what the svg says
Its impressive quiz. However it might be nice to consider listing "Danzig" as "Gdansk". It did come into my mind in the final seconds, but I did not even bothered to type it (assuming it is not counted as a state at all), because i was not missing a G-letter answer...
Could sb explain to me how Andorra bordered Germany? Vichy-France was an 'independent' puppet-like-state as far as I know and Spain was never occupied by Germany.
It was effectively a part of Germany administered by France after both World Wars but was reabsorbed into Germany both times, the first by a plebiscite in 1935 and the second by a referendum and treaty in 1956. I don't consider it a legitimate country.
Good quiz but when I saw the 1940 and 1941 borders I said to myself "Are we really considering those legitimate?" Additionally, I think the Saarland should be considered a puppet of France the same way Slovakia and Croatia are considered puppets of Germany during World War II. Danzig is a hard one. It was neither Poland nor Germany but it wasn't exactly independent since it was a League of Nations mandate. Including or excluding it is a matter of preference.
I'm a (paid) historian, but not of this time period and area, and definitely not of WWI/WWII history. I struggled with the puppet states, but good to learn some new things. Have heard of Saar but not of 'countries' like west ukraine and kuban. I guess some of those were created in the aftermath of the Russian revolution, with the whites and whatnot? And what on earth is 'bottleneck'?
Also, technically you could count two short lived states during the German revolution of 1918-19, the People's State of Bavaria and the Bavarian Council Republic (or soviet republic) that followed it.
Don't understand the map, and don't understand the explanatory note for the people who don't understand the map. Maybe add an explanatory note to explain the explanatory note?
The large map that serves as the "background" is set in the present day and thus all countries there currently border Germany
Now, take for example the smaller map of the north of Norway, in which Germany bordered Sweden, the USSR and Finland ,this part of the map is set during the time the Nazis occupied Norway, thus it gets it's own inset
This is a great quiz idea, but the instructions are sorely lacking. Criticizing users for not understanding your vague/incomplete directions is really not a constructive solution either.
The UK (Kenya and others);
Australia (New Guinea);
China (Tsingtao);
South Africa (German South West Africa)
& The USA (American occupation of Austria).
Further, the WW2 map is inconsistent on "what counts as Germany": occupied France (including Algeria?) is Germany but the occupied parts of the Balkans and Northern Africa are not?
Great quiz in any case.
The large map that serves as the "background" is set in the present day and thus all countries there currently border Germany
Now, take for example the smaller map of the north of Norway, in which Germany bordered Sweden, the USSR and Finland ,this part of the map is set during the time the Nazis occupied Norway, thus it gets it's own inset