home
Menu
Create
Random
0
0
0
thumbnail

Every MLB Team's 10 Best The Show Players

Can you name the Top 10 overall rated players on every MLB team in MLB The Show 24?
Quiz by Lock3JDubs
Rate:
Last updated: May 28, 2024
You have not attempted this quiz yet.
More quiz info >>
First submittedMay 28, 2024
Times taken62
Average score8.3%
Report this quizReport
Quiz and answer stats >>
Friends stats >>
59:59
Enter player here:
0
 / 300 guessed
The quiz is paused. You have remaining.
Scoring
You scored / = %
This beats or equals % of test takers also scored 100%
The average score is
Your high score is
Your fastest time is
Keep scrolling down for answers and more stats ...
 
 
Yankees
1
99
Aaron Judge
2
95
Gerrit Cole
3
91
Juan Soto
4
86
Clay Holmes
5
85
Gleyber Torres
6
82
Nestor Cortes
7
81
Marcus Stroman
8
77
Anthony Volpe
9
77
Anthony Rizzo
10
77
Giancarlo Stanton
 
 
 
 
 
Orioles
1
91
Adley Rutschman
2
88
Corbin Burnes
3
88
Kyle Bradish
4
87
Gunnar Henderson
5
86
Felix Bautista
6
83
Anthony Santander
7
83
Yennier Cano
8
82
Ryan Mountcastle
9
80
Cedric Mullins
10
79
Craig Kimbrel
 
 
 
 
 
Twins
1
88
Pablo Lopez
2
86
Byron Buxton
3
85
Jhoan Duran
4
84
Royce Lewis
5
84
Carlos Correa
6
83
Chris Paddack
7
82
Edouard Julien
8
81
Joe Ryan
9
81
Max Kepler
10
78
Caleb Thielbar
 
 
 
 
 
Athletics
1
78
Brent Rooker
2
78
Zack Gelof
3
77
Paul Blackburn
4
77
Alex Wood
5
76
Zach Jackson
6
74
Esteury Ruiz
7
74
Shea Langeliers
8
73
JP Sears
9
73
Scott Alexander
10
72
Ryan Noda
 
 
 
 
 
Marlins
1
91
Tanner Scott
2
89
Eury Perez
3
83
Jake Burger
4
83
Jazz Chisholm Jr.
5
83
Sandy Alcantara
6
82
A.J. Puk
7
82
Jesus Luzardo
8
80
Braxton Garrett
9
78
Josh Bell
10
77
Bryan De La Cruz
 
 
 
 
 
Cubs
1
88
Cody Bellinger
2
88
Dansby Swanson
3
85
Justin Steele
4
84
Seiya Suzuki
5
83
Nico Hoerner
6
82
Adbert Alzolay
7
81
Christopher Morel
8
81
Kyle Hendricks
9
80
Patrick Wisdom
10
79
Ian Happ
 
 
 
 
 
Cardinals
1
91
Paul Goldschmidt
2
89
Sonny Gray
3
87
Ryan Helsley
4
86
Nolan Arenado
5
84
Tommy Edman
6
84
Willson Contreras
7
82
Lars Nootbaar
8
80
Nolan Gorman
9
79
Kyle Gibson
10
77
Brendan Donovan
 
 
 
 
 
Giants
1
88
Logan Webb
2
86
Camilo Doval
3
81
Jorge Soler
4
81
Matt Chapman
5
81
Wilmer Flores
6
78
Thairo Estrada
7
77
Alex Cobb
8
77
Taylor Rogers
9
76
J.D. Davis
10
76
Robbie Ray
 
 
Red Sox
1
87
Rafael Devers
2
83
Chris Martin
3
83
Kenley Jansen
4
80
Liam Hendriks
5
80
Masataka Yoshida
6
79
Triston Casas
7
79
Nick Pivetta
8
77
Jarren Duran
9
77
Tyler O'Neill
10
76
Trevor Story
 
 
 
 
 
Guardians
1
90
Jose Ramirez
2
87
Emmanuel Clase
3
82
Josh Naylor
4
81
Shane Bieber
5
81
Tanner Bibee
6
80
Triston McKenzie
7
78
Andres Gimenez
8
78
Gavin Williams
9
76
Scott Barlow
10
76
Sam Hentges
 
 
 
 
 
White Sox
1
89
Luis Robert Jr.
2
73
Eloy Jimenez
3
72
Garrett Crochet
4
72
Yoan Moncada
5
72
John Brebbia
6
71
Andrew Vaughn
7
71
Michael Kopech
8
71
Andrew Benintendi
9
71
Paul DeJong
10
70
Michael Soroka
 
 
 
 
 
Mariners
1
93
Julio Rodriguez
2
88
Luis Castillo
3
85
George Kirby
4
84
Andres Munoz
5
84
Cal Raleigh
6
82
Logan Gilbert
7
81
Mitch Garver
8
79
Matt Brash
9
78
Luke Raley
10
77
Bryce Miller
 
 
 
 
 
Mets
1
92
Francisco Lindor
2
90
Pete Alonso
3
89
Edwin Diaz
4
86
Kodai Senga
5
82
Brandon Nimmo
6
82
Jose Quintana
7
80
Francisco Alvarez
8
80
Jeff McNeil
9
78
Brooks Raley
10
78
Sean Manaea
 
 
 
 
 
Reds
1
84
Matt McLain
2
81
Alexis Diaz
3
80
Tejay Antone
4
80
TJ Friedl
5
79
Elly De La Cruz
6
78
Hunter Greene
7
78
Spencer Steer
8
77
Nick Lodolo
9
76
Noelvi Marte
10
76
Andrew Abbott
 
 
 
 
 
Diamondbacks
1
91
Corbin Carroll
2
91
Zac Gallen
3
89
Ketel Marte
4
88
Christian Walker
5
83
Merrill Kelly
6
82
Lourdes Gurriel Jr.
7
81
Eduardo Rodriguez
8
80
Gabriel Moreno
9
80
Paul Sewald
10
78
Geraldo Perdomo
 
 
 
 
 
Rockies
1
88
Nolan Jones
2
78
Ryan McMahon
3
76
Cal Quantrill
4
75
Ezequiel Tovar
5
74
German Marquez
6
73
Charlie Blackmon
7
72
Brendan Rodgers
8
72
Justin Lawrence
9
71
Daniel Bard
10
71
Kris Bryant
 
 
Rays
1
88
Yandy Diaz
2
88
Pete Fairbanks
3
87
Shane McClanahan
4
85
Randy Arozarena
5
84
Isaac Paredes
6
83
Drew Rasmussen
7
83
Jose Siri
8
83
Zach Eflin
9
81
Brandon Lowe
10
80
Jason Adam
 
 
 
 
 
Tigers
1
86
Tarik Skubal
2
79
Kerry Carpenter
3
77
Jake Rogers
4
77
Shelby Miller
5
76
Spencer Torkelson
6
76
Alex Lange
7
76
Matt Manning
8
76
Andrew Chafin
9
75
Riley Greene
10
75
Kenta Maeda
 
 
 
 
 
Astros
1
96
Yordan Alvarez
2
93
Jose Altuve
3
92
Kyle Tucker
4
90
Justin Verlander
5
87
Bryan Abreu
6
87
Alex Bregman
7
86
Chas McCormick
8
85
Josh Hader
9
84
Framber Valdez
10
82
Yainer Diaz
 
 
 
 
 
Rangers
1
98
Corey Seager
2
93
Adolis Garcia
3
92
Jacob deGrom
4
90
Marcus Semien
5
87
Max Scherzer
6
85
Josh Jung
7
84
Nathan Eovaldi
8
83
Jonah Heim
9
82
Evan Carter
10
82
Jose Leclerc
 
 
 
 
 
Phillies
1
93
Zack Wheeler
2
92
Trea Turner
3
91
Bryce Harper
4
87
Aaron Nola
5
87
JT Realmuto
6
83
Jose Alvarado
7
82
Bryson Stott
8
82
Jeff Hoffman
9
81
Ranger Suarez
10
80
Alec Bohm
 
 
 
 
 
Brewers
1
86
William Contreras
2
84
Devin Williams
3
84
Willy Adames
4
82
Freddy Peralta
5
81
Brandon Woodruff
6
80
Christian Yelich
7
79
Jakob Junis
8
79
Rhys Hoskins
9
78
Joel Payamps
10
76
Aaron Ashby
 
 
 
 
 
Dodgers
1
99
Shohei Ohtani
2
99
Mookie Betts
3
94
Freddie Freeman
4
91
Clayton Kershaw
5
90
Tyler Glasnow
6
87
Evan Phillips
7
87
Will Smith
8
85
Teoscar Hernandez
9
83
James Outman
10
83
Max Muncy
 
 
 
 
 
Blue Jays
1
90
Kevin Gausman
2
90
Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
3
89
Bo Bichette
4
82
George Springer
5
81
Jose Berrios
6
80
Justin Turner
7
80
Chris Bassitt
8
80
Danny Jansen
9
79
Daulton Varsho
10
79
Kevin Kiermaier
 
 
 
 
 
Royals
1
92
Bobby Witt Jr.
2
80
Cole Ragans
3
79
Seth Lugo
4
77
Brady Singer
5
77
Freddy Fermin
6
77
Will Smith
7
77
Hunter Renfroe
8
77
Michael Wacha
9
76
Kyle Wright
10
75
Vinnie Pasquantino
 
 
 
 
 
Angels
1
99
Mike Trout
2
83
Brandon Drury
3
79
Taylor Ward
4
79
Matt Moore
5
77
Reid Detmers
6
77
Patrick Sandoval
7
76
Logan O'Hoppe
8
76
Luis Rengifo
9
75
Chase Silseth
10
75
Aaron Hicks
 
 
 
 
 
Braves
1
99
Ronald Acuna Jr.
2
97
Spencer Strider
3
96
Austin Riley
4
95
Matt Olson
5
89
Michael Harris II
6
89
Sean Murphy
7
88
Ozzie Albies
8
85
Chris Sale
9
85
Max Fried
10
82
Raisel Iglesias
 
 
 
 
 
Nationals
1
83
Lane Thomas
2
79
Joey Gallo
3
77
Stone Garrett
4
76
Hunter Harvey
5
75
Eddie Rosario
6
75
Joey Meneses
7
74
C.J. Abrams
8
74
Josiah Gray
9
72
MacKenzie Gore
10
72
Nick Senzel
 
 
 
 
 
Pirates
1
92
David Bednar
2
83
Bryan Reynolds
3
82
Mitch Keller
4
81
Ke'Bryan Hayes
5
79
Oneil Cruz
6
78
Andrew McCutchen
7
77
Johan Oviedo
8
76
Aroldis Chapman
9
76
Jack Suwinski
10
73
Jared Triolo
 
 
 
 
 
Padres
1
92
Fernando Tatis
2
91
Manny Machado
3
88
Ha-Seong Kim
4
84
Joe Musgrove
5
84
Xander Bogaerts
6
83
Dylan Cease
7
79
Yu Darvish
8
77
Robert Suarez
9
76
Luis Campusano
10
73
Yuki Matsui
 
 
 
Your Next Quiz
• Champions League Winners
• Biggest Cities in Europe
• Countries by First and Last Two Letters
• Pin US States on a Borderless Map - Sudden Death
Comments
No comments yet
Save Your Progress
Copyright H Brothers Inc, 2008–2025
Contact Us | Go To Top | View Mobile Site