I like the idea behind this quiz, but some things are off. Neil is actually spelt Neal. Bae or Baelfire should also be accepted. Graham was actually the sheriff which is completely different than the police. Teacup should also be accepted for chipped cup. It would probably actually be the enchanted wardrobe as well, but that is a pretty bad clue. Maybe something along the lines of, "What did Emma and August come through that was carved by Gepetto?" would be better.
I made the primary answer "Neil" because most people probably don't know that it's spelled Neal in the show. Neil is the most common spelling for the name so I made it easier for people. But when you type in "Neal" that is also an option that works, as is Bae and Baelfire. :)