While French is one of two official languages in Canada, it is pretty hard to think of Toronto as a French speaking urban area. Surprisingly tough quiz.
Not when I've been there - India I mean. It may not be many people's first language, but it is spoken all over the place, and not just to foreigners. I've often heard Indians talking amongst themselves switching with gay abandon back and forth between English and other languages, most usually Hindi I presume.
I think this quiz would be better as biggest cities where at least x% of people speak the language. In a lot of cases it works as is, but just because English is an official language in India, doesn't mean you'll be able to go to those cities and have a conversation with most people you meet in English.
Why would being able to go to the city and have a conversation with most people you meet be the criteria though? If you speak fluent English and Brazilian Portuguese, you can have a conversation with most Spanish speakers. If you speak fluent English, you can have a conversation with most people in any major German city as well. Most people would not want to count Berlin as an "English-speaking" city, nor Barcelona as a "Portuguese-speaking" one, and that's not even getting into one-way or mutually unintelligible dialects, which exist in at least 4 or 5 languages that I'm aware of.
Should it need to be the official *and* commonly-spoken language? What about regions where a substantial minority speaks a different language? Should Guangzhou be excluded because of the prevalence of Cantonese speakers?
It's not obvious to me that the way it's done here is ideal, but it's really not obvious that there is a better way to do it either.
Man this quiz is everywhere lol. I think your definition of what you define as urban area and what your source define as urban area might be slightly skewed cause several of the URBAN populations of these cities are way off compared to the populations of Universally accepted sources and you’re missing several cities in different categories as well. Also a good majority of the populations of cities in the English and French speaking sections of the quiz don’t have very many of the languages speakers at all. Especially many of the Indian and African Cities listed. Just cause the country has it as Official language doesn’t mean a lot of people speak it. This quiz is a great idea but definitely needs a source change and some city changes too. Also yes I did read your blog on Metropolitan areas and Urban areas but even using your own system as outlined in your blog you’ve misclassified some the cities as well.
The notes are pretty explicit about counting official languages whether or not there is a large population in the city that speak them. If you don't want that... make a different version. Not really much point in complaining that the quiz does the thing it says it's doing.
There is definitely no such thing as a "universally accepted source" about what exactly defines the urban area of a city.
Also, instead of saying like "you are missing several cities", how about naming a few of them?
Should it need to be the official *and* commonly-spoken language? What about regions where a substantial minority speaks a different language? Should Guangzhou be excluded because of the prevalence of Cantonese speakers?
It's not obvious to me that the way it's done here is ideal, but it's really not obvious that there is a better way to do it either.
The notes are pretty explicit about counting official languages whether or not there is a large population in the city that speak them. If you don't want that... make a different version. Not really much point in complaining that the quiz does the thing it says it's doing.
There is definitely no such thing as a "universally accepted source" about what exactly defines the urban area of a city.
Also, instead of saying like "you are missing several cities", how about naming a few of them?