| The only player in history to ... | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Be walked intentionally more than 100 times in a single season | Barry Bonds | 89%
|
| Have his number retired by every Major League team | Jackie Robinson | 89%
|
| Hit 40 home runs and win 10 games as a pitcher in the same season | Shohei Ohtani | 84%
|
| Get married to Marilyn Monroe | Joe DiMaggio | 79%
|
| Have 3,000 hits as a Yankee | Derek Jeter | 78%
|
| Have his number retired by 3 teams that he actually played with (hint: Angels, Astros, Rangers) | Nolan Ryan | 77%
|
| Date Jennifer Lopez | Alex Rodriguez | 76%
|
| Have 3,000 hits in the Major League and 1,000 in Japan | Ichiro Suzuki | 70%
|
| Hit sixty home runs in a season three separate times | Sammy Sosa | 64%
|
| Be inducted into the Hall of Fame as a Kansas City Royal | George Brett | 58%
|
| Hit 150 home runs both left-handed and right-handed | Mickey Mantle | 57%
|
| Be cryogenically frozen after death | Ted Williams | 57%
|
| Win seven Cy Young awards | Roger Clemens | 52%
|
| Be featured on a tobacco card worth more than $3 million | Honus Wagner | 51%
|
| Win a home run title without hitting a ball over the fence (hint: 1909) | Ty Cobb | 47%
|
| Hit more than 300 home runs and have a last name that is a fruit | Darryl Strawberry | 46%
|
| Win a Cy Young award as a knuckleballer | R. A. Dickey | 43%
|
| Be born with only one hand | Jim Abbott | 36%
|
| Hit two grand slams in one inning (hint: Cardinals, 1999) | Fernando Tatís | 34%
|
| Pitch a perfect game in the World Series | Don Larsen | 31%
|
| Hit a walk-off home run in Game 7 of the World Series (hint: Pirates, 1960) | Bill Mazeroski | 27%
|
| Appear on the cover of Rolling Stone magazine (hint: Tigers, 1977) | Mark Fidrych | 16%
|
| Throw consecutive no-hitters (hint: Reds, 1938) | Johnny Vander Meer | 12%
|