| Scandal | Athlete | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Allegedly killed Nicole Brown and Ronald Goldman | O.J. Simpson | 94%
|
| Temporarily quit the PGA tour after multiple extra-marital affairs were revealed | Tiger Woods | 87%
|
| Bit Evander Holyfield's ear | Mike Tyson | 84%
|
| Stripped of seven Tour de France titles after doping investigation | Lance Armstrong | 82%
|
| Ran a dog-fighting operation | Michael Vick | 72%
|
| Took steroids and then broke baseball's all-time and single-season home run records | Barry Bonds | 65%
|
| Bet on baseball games while managing the Reds | Pete Rose | 58%
|
| Conspired to attack a rival figure skater | Tonya Harding | 54%
|
| Knocked his fiancée unconscious in an elevator | Ray Rice | 53%
|
| Hits his 4 year old son with a switch | Adrian Peterson | 49%
|
| Scored a goal with his hand in a World Cup game against England | Diego Maradona | 47%
|
| Headbutted an Italian player during World Cup finals | Zinedine Zidane | 47%
|
| Accused of three murders in the Boston area, convicted of one | Aaron Hernandez | 46%
|
| Bit opposing soccer players on three separate occasions | Luis Suárez | 44%
|
| Had a fake girlfriend | Manti T'eo | 40%
|
| Took steroids. Stripped of 100m dash gold medal in 1988 | Ben Johnson | 36%
|
| Shot himself in the leg | Plaxico Burress | 33%
|
| Made it rain in a strip club, and then assaulted a stripper who tried to collect his $1 bills | Pacman Jones | 15%
|