| km2 | Hint | Island | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 25,462 | Etna | Sicily | 100%
|
| 23,812 | Cagliari | Sardinia | 98%
|
| 223.5 | Napoleon | Elba | 89%
|
| 46.4 | 30 kilometres off of Naples | Ischia | 45%
|
| 50.9 | Italian for donkey | Asinara | 42%
|
| 37.3 | Largest of Aeolian Islands | Lipari | 35%
|
| 26.1 | Italian for salt mine | Salina | 35%
|
| 83 | Raisin wine | Pantelleria | 34%
|
| 108.9 | Off the coast of #2, linked by bridge | Sant'Antioco | 31%
|
| 51.3 | First Pope | San Pietro | 26%
|