| Original Name | Years used | Current Name | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| The Wednesday | 1867 - 1929 | Sheffield Wednesday | 96%
|
| Argyle | 1886 - 1903 | Plymouth Argyle | 66%
|
| Everton Athletic | 1892 | Liverpool | 56%
|
| Newton Heath LYR | 1878 - 1902 | Manchester United | 55%
|
| Small Heath Alliance | 1875 - 1888 | Birmingham City | 32%
|
| Boscombe | 1899 - 1923 | AFC Bournemouth | 31%
|
| Abbey United | 1912 - 1951 | Cambridge United | 28%
|
| St. Marks (West Gorton) | 1880 - 1887 | Manchester City | 18%
|
| St. Domingo's | 1878 - 1879 | Everton | 17%
|
| Headington United | 1893 - 1960 | Oxford United | 17%
|
| Dial Square | 1886 | Arsenal | 15%
|
| Singers | 1883 - 1898 | Coventry City | 9%
|
| Black Arabs | 1883 - 1884 | Bristol Rovers | 8%
|
| New Brompton | 1893 - 1912 | Gillingham | 5%
|
| Christ Church | 1874 - 1877 | Bolton Wanderers | 4%
|
| _______ Pelham | 1878 - 1879 | Grimsby Town | 3%
|
| Pine Villa | 1895 - 1899 | Oldham Athletic | 3%
|
| Glyn Cricket Club | 1881 - 1886 | Leyton Orient | 2%
|
| _______ Central | 1940 - 1989 | Salford City | 2%
|