| Appearances | Duration | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 388 | 2011 – 2022 | Steve Cook | 100%
|
| 375 | 2010 – 2011 2014 – now | Adam Smith | 88%
|
| 324 | 2011 – 2020 | Simon Francis | 88%
|
| 265 | 2011 – 2020 | Charlie Daniels | 75%
|
| 310 | 1995 – 20022004 – 2007 | Eddie Howe | 75%
|
| 726 | 1992 – 20072009 – 2013 | Steve Fletcher | 75%
|
| 312 | 2010 – 2019 | Marc Pugh | 50%
|
| 222 | 1991 – 19982000 – 2003 | Andrew Surman | 25%
|
| 301 | 2005 – 2018 | Brett Pitman | 25%
|
| 407 | 1997 – 2007 | James Hayter | 25%
|
| 483 | 1994 – 2008 | Neil Young | 25%
|
| 378 | 1924 – 1933 | Ron Eyre | 13%
|
| 240 | 2005 – 2012 | Shaun Cooper | 13%
|
| 277 | 2000 – 20012003 – 2012 | Warren Cummings | 13%
|
| 255 | 2010 – 2020 | Harry Arter | 0%
|
| 398 | 1968 – 1979 | Keith Miller | 0%
|
| 436 | 1958 – 1969 | Ray Bumstead | 0%
|
| 441 | 1984 – 1995 | Sean O'Driscoll | 0%
|
| 317 | 1904 – 1920 | Stephen Purches | 0%
|
| 389 | 1952 – 1962 | Tommy Godwin | 0%
|