| # of Fans | Division | Team | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 23,789,450 | AL East | New York Yankees | 99%
|
| 20,106,387 | AL East | Boston Red Sox | 93%
|
| 20,307,037 | NL East | Atlanta Braves | 90%
|
| 18,425,056 | NL Central | Chicago Cubs | 90%
|
| 8,137,226 | NL West | Los Angeles Dodgers | 87%
|
| 11,095,094 | NL West | San Francisco Giants | 87%
|
| 4,517,874 | AL Central | Minnesota Twins | 86%
|
| 7,237,208 | NL East | New York Mets | 86%
|
| 5,806,971 | NL East | Philadelphia Phillies | 86%
|
| 4,602,667 | AL East | Baltimore Orioles | 85%
|
| 4,824,354 | AL Central | Kansas City Royals | 84%
|
| 3,970,562 | NL Central | Milwaukee Brewers | 84%
|
| 8,730,179 | NL Central | St. Louis Cardinals | 84%
|
| 10,275,941 | AL West | Texas Rangers | 84%
|
| 4,056,240 | NL West | Arizona Diamondbacks | 83%
|
| 3,035,525 | AL Central | Chicago White Sox | 83%
|
| 5,102,696 | NL Central | Cincinnati Reds | 83%
|
| 4,530,586 | NL West | Colorado Rockies | 83%
|
| 7,589,747 | AL Central | Detroit Tigers | 83%
|
| 3,738,013 | AL West | Oakland Athletics | 83%
|
| 4,169,171 | NL Central | Pittsburgh Pirates | 83%
|
| 3,329,816 | NL West | San Diego Padres | 83%
|
| 4,331,531 | AL Central | Cleveland Indians | 82%
|
| 6,437,770 | AL West | Los Angeles Angels | 82%
|
| 6,646,472 | AL West | Houston Astros | 81%
|
| 2,525,967 | NL East | Miami Marlins | 81%
|
| 6,437,770 | AL West | Seattle Mariners | 81%
|
| 2,765,617 | AL East | Tampa Bay Rays | 81%
|
| 211,264 | AL East | Toronto Blue Jays | 80%
|
| 2,804,064 | NL East | Washington Nationals | 80%
|