| Pos | Club | Years | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| DF | AC Milan | 1984—2009 | Paolo Maldini | 98%
|
| FW | Bayern Munich | 2008—2025 | Thomas Müller | 95%
|
| DF | Barcelona | 1999—2014 | Carles Puyol | 91%
|
| FW | AS Roma | 1993—2017 | Francesco Totti | 90%
|
| GK | Dynamo Moscow | 1950—1970 | Lev Yashin | 89%
|
| MF | Manchester United | 1993—2013 | Paul Scholes | 89%
|
| MF | Manchester United | 1990—2014 | Ryan Giggs | 85%
|
| DF | AC Milan | 1977—1997 | Franco Baresi | 70%
|
| Sub(DF) | Manchester United | 1992—2011 | Gary Neville | 70%
|
| MF* | Liverpool | 1996—2013 | Jamie Carragher | 64%
|
| DF | Arsenal | 1983—2002 | Tony Adams | 64%
|
| MF | Southampton | 1986—2002 | Matt Le Tissier | 46%
|
| Sub(FW) | Inter Milan | 1960—1977 | Sandro Mazzola | 11%
|