| WAR | Years | Player | Pos. | Awards | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 69.1 | 1982 - 2001 | Tony Gwynn | RF | 5x GG, 7x SS | 100%
|
| 25.8 | 2019 - Active | Manny Machado | 3B | 2x SS | 96%
|
| 24.6 | 2019 - Active | Fernando Tatis Jr. | RF | GG, 2x SS | 84%
|
| 26.8 | 2002 - 2009 | Jake Peavy | P | 2007 Cy Young | 76%
|
| 32.0 | 1973 - 1980 | Dave Winfield | RF | 2x GG | 68%
|
| 25.8 | 1993 - 2008 | Trevor Hoffman | P | 64%
| |
| 20.4 | 2006 - 2010 | Adrián González | 1B | 2x GG | 60%
|
| 17.5 | 1995 - 1998 | Ken Caminiti | 3B | 3x GG, SS, 1996 MVP | 56%
|
| 19.8 | 1973 - 1980 | Randy Jones | P | 1976 Cy Young | 52%
|
| 17.2 | 1969 - 1974 | Nate Colbert | 1B | 40%
| |
| 16.9 | 1981 - 1986 | Terry Kennedy | C | SS | 24%
|
| 18.3 | 2007 - 2014, 2018 | Chase Headley | 3B | GG, SS | 20%
|
| 16.4 | 1981 - 1990 | Eric Show | P | 20%
| |
| 15.1 | 2021 - 2024 | Ha-Seong Kim | SS | GG | 20%
|
| 17.8 | 1999 - 2005 | Phil Nevin | 3B | 16%
| |
| 15.7 | 2000 - 2006 | Ryan Klesko | 1B | 16%
| |
| 20.2 | 1989 - 1995 | Andy Benes | P | 12%
| |
| 22.5 | 1993 - 1999, 2004 | Andy Ashby | P | 8%
| |
| 17.4 | 2003 - 2009 | Brian Giles | RF | 8%
| |
| 19.8 | 1977 - 1980 | Gene Tenace | C | 8%
| |
| 15.8 | 1983 - 1984, 1986 - 1991 | Ed Whitson | P | 4%
| |
| 19.0 | 1977 - 1983 | Gene Richards | LF | 4%
| |
| 15.4 | 1988 - 1993 | Greg Harris | P | 0%
| |
| 14.7 | 1994 - 1998 | Joey Hamilton | P | 0%
|