MLB St. Louis Cardinals Best Players

Can you name the 24 best players to play for the St. Louis Cardinals franchise based on total bWAR accumulated for the team.
years and awards = during time with team not overall career
Pos. = Position played most during time with team
ROY = Rookie of the Year GG = Gold Glove, SS = Silver Slugger
Bolded = In the Hall of Fame
Quiz by
lhr131415
Rate:
Last updated: August 1, 2025
You have not attempted this quiz yet.
First submittedJuly 16, 2025
Times taken60
Average score50.0%
Report this quizReport
7:00
Enter answer here
0
 / 24 guessed
The quiz is paused. You have remaining.
Scoring
You scored / = %
This beats or equals % of test takers also scored 100%
The average score is
Your high score is
Your fastest time is
Keep scrolling down for answers and more stats ...
WAR
Years
Player
Pos.
Awards
128.6
1941- 1963
Stan Musial
1B
1943 1946 1948 MVP
91.5
1915 - 1926, 1933
Rogers Hornsby
2B
1925 MVP
89.1
1959 - 1975
Bob Gibson
P
9x GG, 1968 1970 Cy Young 1968 MVP
88.6
2001 - 2011, 2022
Albert Pujols
1B
2x GG, 6x SS, 2001 ROY 2005 2008 2009 MVP
66.0
1982 - 1996
Ozzie Smith
SS
11x GG, SS
58.1
1955 - 1965
Ken Boyer
3B
5x GG, 1964 MVP
52.7
1938 - 1953
Enos Slaughter
RF
 
45.3
2005 - 2023
Adam Wainwright
P
2x GG, SS
45.0
1968 - 1980
Ted Simmons
C
SS
42.2
1958 - 1969
Curt Flood
CF
7x GG
42.1
1930 - 1937
Dizzy Dean
P
1934 MVP
41.7
1964 - 1979
Lou Brock
LF
 
41.6
2004 - 2022
Yadier Molina
C
9x GG, SS
39.8
1932 - 1940, 1947 - 1948
Joe Medwick
LF
1937 MVP
39.6
1940 - 1952
Harry Brecheen
P
 
37.9
2000 - 2007
Jim Edmonds
CF
6x GG, SS
37.7
1936 - 1941
Johnny Mize
1B
 
37.6
1990 - 2001, 2004
Ray Lankford
CF
 
35.7
1884 - 1887, 1892
Bob Caruthers
RF
 
35.6
1945 - 1956, 1961 - 1963
Red Schoendienst
2B
 
34.4
1922 - 1932
Jim Bottomley
1B
1928 MVP
34.4
1974 - 1983
Keith Hernandez
1B
6x GG, SS, 1979 MVP
33.9
1927 - 1937
Frankie Frisch
2B
1931 MVP
32.5
1891 - 1896, 1901
Theodore Breitenstein
P
 
Save Your Stats
Your Next Quiz
Name all 50 states in the USA. Easy, right?
20 random countries have been removed from the map of the world! Can you identify them in 3 minutes?
Drag the flag onto the correct state. Careful, though! One wrong move and the game ends.
Drag the flag onto the correct country. Careful, though! One wrong move and the game ends.
Comments
No comments yet