| WAR | Years | Player | Pos. | Awards | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 88.6 | 2001 - 2011, 2022 | Albert Pujols | 1B | 2x GG, 6x SS, 2001 ROY 2005 2008 2009 MVP | 100%
|
| 66.0 | 1982 - 1996 | Ozzie Smith | SS | 11x GG, SS | 98%
|
| 128.6 | 1941- 1963 | Stan Musial | 1B | 1943 1946 1948 MVP | 95%
|
| 89.1 | 1959 - 1975 | Bob Gibson | P | 9x GG, 1968 1970 Cy Young 1968 MVP | 93%
|
| 45.3 | 2005 - 2023 | Adam Wainwright | P | 2x GG, SS | 90%
|
| 41.6 | 2004 - 2022 | Yadier Molina | C | 9x GG, SS | 90%
|
| 91.5 | 1915 - 1926, 1933 | Rogers Hornsby | 2B | 1925 MVP | 81%
|
| 37.9 | 2000 - 2007 | Jim Edmonds | CF | 6x GG, SS | 76%
|
| 41.7 | 1964 - 1979 | Lou Brock | LF | 74%
| |
| 45.0 | 1968 - 1980 | Ted Simmons | C | SS | 64%
|
| 42.1 | 1930 - 1937 | Dizzy Dean | P | 1934 MVP | 57%
|
| 34.4 | 1974 - 1983 | Keith Hernandez | 1B | 6x GG, SS, 1979 MVP | 48%
|
| 58.1 | 1955 - 1965 | Ken Boyer | 3B | 5x GG, 1964 MVP | 38%
|
| 35.6 | 1945 - 1956, 1961 - 1963 | Red Schoendienst | 2B | 38%
| |
| 52.7 | 1938 - 1953 | Enos Slaughter | RF | 36%
| |
| 39.8 | 1932 - 1940, 1947 - 1948 | Joe Medwick | LF | 1937 MVP | 29%
|
| 42.2 | 1958 - 1969 | Curt Flood | CF | 7x GG | 24%
|
| 33.9 | 1927 - 1937 | Frankie Frisch | 2B | 1931 MVP | 21%
|
| 37.7 | 1936 - 1941 | Johnny Mize | 1B | 19%
| |
| 37.6 | 1990 - 2001, 2004 | Ray Lankford | CF | 19%
| |
| 34.4 | 1922 - 1932 | Jim Bottomley | 1B | 1928 MVP | 14%
|
| 39.6 | 1940 - 1952 | Harry Brecheen | P | 2%
| |
| 32.5 | 1891 - 1896, 1901 | Theodore Breitenstein | P | 2%
| |
| 35.7 | 1884 - 1887, 1892 | Bob Caruthers | RF | 0%
|