Fun quiz! Could have done with a bit more time. Missed T though I think the ones I tried should be accepted, unless there's a minimum number of performances needed to make the cut:
Two Strangers (Carry A Cake Across New York)
Titanique
Both currently running. The latter opened four days ago to be fair! Also, for W:
The A-L musicals Wikipedia article (wrongly) has this as Off-Broadway. I hope someone fixes it! It's a pretty egregious omission given that it won multiple Tonys.
I got a measly 9, my musical knowledge isn't so strong haha
btw I think you should accept Shrek on its own
Also yeah I fixed that for Shrek and all the other ":the musical" ones :)
Two Strangers (Carry A Cake Across New York)
Titanique
Both currently running. The latter opened four days ago to be fair! Also, for W:
The Woman in White
Two Strangers and Titanique were both just new enough that I didn't have them :D
I also added Woman in White
Would you consider adding Illinoise? (based on the Sufjan Stevens album)