Politics: Anarchism - The Economy

This is a quiz based on how Anarchists view human nature, which is covered in the AQA A-Level Politics Specification: Max Stirner (1806-1856) Peter Kropotkin (1842-1921) Mikhail Bakunin (1814-1876) Pierre-Joseph Proudhon (1809-1865) Emma Goldman (1869-1940)
Quiz by
billyn
Rate:
Last updated: June 13, 2024
You have not attempted this quiz yet.
First submittedJanuary 19, 2024
Times taken2
Report this quizReport
10:00
Enter answer here
0
 / 5 guessed
The quiz is paused. You have remaining.
Scoring
You scored / = %
This beats or equals % of test takers also scored 100%
The average score is
Your high score is
Your fastest time is
Keep scrolling down for answers and more stats ...
Answer
Hint
Murray Rothbard (1926-1995)
 
Noam Chomsky (1928-)
 
Peter Kropotkin (1842-1921)
This key thinker argues capitalism was to be replaced by the communist system of small units which should, as far as possible, be self-sufficient:
-His conversion (from socialism to anarchism) was mainly the result of his visit to the Jura Federation in Switzerland where he observed an experiment in cooperative production and living among a community of watch-makers who pooled their resources and the profits of their work.
-These communities, based on a single occupation, were self-governing cooperatives where the workers operated without any government and shared the fruits of their production equally.
-His plans were mainly described in 'Fields, Factories and Workshops' (1898).
-His brand of anarcho-communism proposed the creation of natural communities (communes).
-These would be smaller-scale communities than those described by Bakunin.
-His argument was that if people were free to join whichever community they wished, they would not be subjected to any force.
-He stated, 'Don't compete! - Competition is always injurious to the species, and you have plenty of resources to avoid it!'
-Without scarcity, he argued, there would be no competition, and without competition, there would be no inequality.
-In 'Mutual Aid' (1902), he insisted that the competitive economic world was not inevitable - with cooperation and communal living, mankind could free itself from the structures of being forced into competition for scarce resources.
Pierre-Joseph Proudhon (1809-1865)
This key thinker argues people should be divided into independent productive units, trading with each other on a mutually beneficial basis:
-In his seminal work, 'What Is Property?' (1840), he is famous for his assertion that 'property is theft'.
-He did not totally oppose private property, merely property that was used to oppress workers or to promote inequality.
-Workers and peasants, he accepted, might own what they needed to manage their own production - these he called 'possessions' to distinguish them from 'property'.
-He is often described as a 'libertarian socialist'.
-He agreed with the socialist ideal of the means of production being owned in common and the abolition of the capitalist system of exchange but also advocated the abolition of any kind of government.
-Socialists saw the state as a vital part of the creation and maintenance of workers' rights, but he rejected it on the grounds that it would become oppressive.
-His brand of anarchism was to be decentralised and made up of communities of workers who had come together freely to form cooperative working groups.
-This theory, known as mutualism, also known as 'contractualism', proposed the replacement of capitalism with a system of exchange based on contracts entered into on a free, mutually beneficial basis.
-He was concerned that workers and peasants should receive the true value of what their labour produced instead of its market value, which was determined by capitalist forces beyond the worker's control.
-He proposed a voucher system to indicate the real value of goods, based on labour input and a national bank to supply funds to independent workers and peasants.
-These funds were to replace the need to make profits.
-He was also a bridge between individualist and collectivist anarchism.
-He was collectivist in that he proposed a federal system of communes, very like those envisaged by Kropotkin, and backed by a 'People's bank' which could recycle surplus funds to these productive units.
-However, he was also individualist as he saw workers and groups of workers freely entering contracts with each other for the exchange of labour and goods.
-His hopes for a reconciliation between individualism and collectivism are summed up in these words, as part of 'What Is Property?' (1840): 'When politics and home life have become one and the same, when economic problems have been solved in such a way that individual and collective interests are identical - all constraints having disappeared - it is evident that we will be in a state of total liberty or anarchy.'.
-His idea of mutualism was influential among 19th-century anarchists, with Kropotkin in particular with his work 'Mutual Aid' (1902), similarly insisting that the competitive economic world was not inevitable. With cooperation and communal living, mankind could free itself from the strictures of being forced into competition for scarce resources.
-Aspects of his mutualism can be seen in the 20th-century cooperative movements (of consumers in Britain and of peasants and workers in the continent of Europe), in the commune movement of the 1960s and 1970s, and even in the current 'fair trade' movement which seeks to ensure that producers in developing countries receive the just reward for their goods.
-Similarly, his ideas of decentralisation can still be seen in the aim of some non-government organisations to promote subsistence production in developing countries to prevent producers from being forced to produce for world commodity markets at prices that discriminate against them and force them into large, artificial productive units.
Emma Goldman (1869-1940)
This key thinker, as a violent opponent of capitalism, was more concerned with liberty than with economic justice but was fundamentally a communist:
-She raged against virtually every enemy of individual liberty - the modern state, religion, nationalism, Marxism, capitalism, patriarchy and bigotry of any kind.
-She campaigned for the abolition of capitalism without expressing any particular preference for what could replace it.
-All she was concerned with was that no one could be free within capitalism.
-In the sense she placed herself in the tradition of 19th-century individualist anarchists.
-Henry Thoreau and Josiah Warren (1798-1874) in the US both advocated a withdrawal of the individual from the capitalist world - rather than selling their labour to capitalist employers, people could obtain their freedom both from the state and from the economic system.
Save Your Stats
Your Next Quiz
Name all 50 states in the USA. Easy, right?
20 random countries have been removed from the map of the world! Can you identify them in 3 minutes?
Drag the flag onto the correct state. Careful, though! One wrong move and the game ends.
Drag the flag onto the correct country. Careful, though! One wrong move and the game ends.
Comments
No comments yet