| Hint | Liar | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| The Liar whose first secret was kissing her sisters boyfriend. | Spencer | 97%
|
| The Liar who was first to kill someone. | Emily | 92%
|
| The Liar who had an inappropriate moment with another Liar's brother. | Hanna | 92%
|
| The Liar who received the first A text. | Alison | 91%
|
| The Liar whose own mother buried her. | Alison | 91%
|
| The Liar who got her hair cut off in the dollhouse. | Aria | 90%
|
| The Liar who was a suspect in two different murders. | Spencer | 90%
|
| The Liar who hasn't killed anyone. | Spencer | 90%
|
| The Liar who joined the A team temporarily. | Spencer | 89%
|
| The Liar who went to jail first. | Alison | 86%
|
| The Liar whose father died. | Emily | 85%
|
| The Liar who has an unwanted stepsister. | Hanna | 85%
|
| The Liar who was kidnapped by A.D. | Hanna | 84%
|
| The Liar who was best friends with A. | Hanna | 84%
|
| The Liar who was tortured by her own husband. | Alison | 83%
|
| The Liar who "never met a scarf she didn't like." | Aria | 83%
|
| The Liar who stole Alison's red jacket. | Emily | 80%
|
| The Liar who is rarely considered a Liar. | Mona | 64%
|