| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| First winner | Richard Hatch | 100%
|
| First person to win the game twice | Sandra Diaz-Twine | 100%
|
| Only man to win twice | Tony Vlachos | 100%
|
| Woman who "got off the couch" | Cirie Fields | 95%
|
| Last member of Ulong, the decimated tribe | Stephenie LaGrossa | 95%
|
| Two-time player voted out first twice | Francesca Hogi | 89%
|
| Most recent winner | Rachel LaMont | 89%
|
| First person to play in back-to-back seasons | Rupert Boneham | 89%
|
| First person to play four times, and only one to play five times | Boston Rob Mariano | 84%
|
| First person to play a "perfect game" | J.T. Thomas | 84%
|
| First person to reach 100 days in the game | Amanda Kimmel | 79%
|
| First winner to have been voted out in the same season | Chris Underwood | 79%
|
| Person who lost the first ever final tribal tiebreaker | Domenick Abbate | 63%
|
| Only person to have played more than once and never left the game | Michele Fitzgerald | 63%
|
| First person voted out in season 1 | Sonja Christopher | 63%
|
| First person to win unanimously | Earl Cole | 58%
|
| Set the record for most Individual Immunity wins in a season | Colby Donaldson | 53%
|
| First person to be voted out multiple times in a season | Burton Roberts | 47%
|
| First person to play an idol (current form) | Yau-Man Chan | 37%
|
| First person to win a firemaking challenge at final 4 | Ian Rosenberger | 26%
|