| Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|
| Cattleman Revolver | 84%
|
| Schofield Revolver | 73%
|
| Lancaster Repeater | 70%
|
| Carbine Repeater | 66%
|
| Double-Action Revolver | 66%
|
| Mauser Pistol | 63%
|
| Bow | 62%
|
| Throwing Knife | 61%
|
| Volcanic Pistol | 60%
|
| Bolt Action Rifle | 58%
|
| Dynamite | 58%
|
| Springfield Rifle | 58%
|
| Rolling Block Rifle | 57%
|
| Sawed-Off Shotgun | 56%
|
| Pump-Action Shotgun | 55%
|
| Tomahawk | 51%
|
| Hunting Knife | 50%
|
| Midnight's Pistol | 50%
|
| Carcano Rifle | 49%
|
| Litchfield Repeater | 49%
|
| Fire Bottle | 47%
|
| Flaco's Revolver | 47%
|
| Semi-Auto Shotgun | 47%
|
| Evans Repeater | 46%
|
| Granger's Revolver | 46%
|
| Repeating Shotgun | 45%
|
| Calloway's Revolver | 44%
|
| Semi-Automatic Pistol | 44%
|
| Varmint Rifle | 44%
|
| Double-Barreled Shotgun | 42%
|
| Micah's Revolver | 42%
|
| LeMat Revolver | 40%
|
| M1899 Pistol | 40%
|
| Civil War Knife | 39%
|
| Rare Rolling Block Rifle | 39%
|
| Machete | 38%
|
| Hatchet | 36%
|
| Rare Shotgun | 36%
|
| John's Cattleman Revolver | 34%
|
| Otis Miller's Revolver | 32%
|
| Broken Pirate Sword | 29%
|
| Poison Throwing Knife | 29%
|
| Antler Knife | 27%
|
| Algernon's Revolver | 25%
|
| Ancient Tomahawk | 25%
|
| High Roller Revolver | 25%
|
| John's Knife | 25%
|
| Volatile Dynamite | 25%
|
| Viking Hatchet | 24%
|
| Cleaver | 23%
|
| Improved Tomahawk | 23%
|
| Volatile Fire Bottle | 23%
|
| Homing Tomahawk | 22%
|
| Improved Throwing Knife | 22%
|
| Double Bit Hatchet | 21%
|
| Jawbone Knife | 19%
|
| Stone Hatchet | 19%
|
| Unarmed | 19%
|
| Wide-Blade Knife | 19%
|
| Ornate Dagger | 18%
|
| Rusted Double Bit Hatchet | 16%
|
| Hunter Hatchet | 14%
|
| Hewing Hatchet | 13%
|
| Rusted Hunter Hatchet | 12%
|