| Position | Season(s) | Club | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4th | 1952–53 | Plymouth Argyle | 80%
|
| 3rd | 1954–55 | Rotherham United | 71%
|
| 5th | 1991–92 | Cambridge United | 69%
|
| 6th | 1955–56, 1958–59 | Bristol Rovers | 65%
|
| 10th | 2006–07 | Colchester United | 63%
|
| 11th | 2002–03 | Gillingham | 58%
|
| 5th | 1901–02 | Lincoln City | 54%
|
| 4th | 1992–93 | Tranmere Rovers | 54%
|
| 7th | 1901–02 | Doncaster Rovers | 53%
|
| 10th | 1992–93 | Peterborough United | 53%
|
| 12th | 1991–92 | Southend United | 52%
|
| 4th | 1961–62 | Scunthorpe United | 51%
|
| 5th | 1930–31 | Port Vale | 49%
|
| 8th | 1997–98 | Stockport County | 49%
|
| 11th | 1997–98 | Crewe Alexandra | 48%
|
| 6th | 1898–99 | Walsall | 48%
|
| 4th | 1946–47 | Chesterfield | 41%
|
| 8th | 1983–84, 1984–85 | Shrewsbury Town | 41%
|
| 6th | 1904–05 | Gainsborough Trinity | 6%
|
| 7th | 1892–93 | Northwich Victoria | 4%
|