| Season | Team | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1959 | Colts | Johnny Unitas | 93%
|
| 1958 | Colts | Johnny Unitas | 93%
|
| 1957 | Colts | Johnny Unitas | 93%
|
| 1959 | Eagles | Norm Van Brocklin | 93%
|
| 1958 | Eagles | Norm Van Brocklin | 93%
|
| 1955 | Rams | Norm Van Brocklin | 93%
|
| 1954 | Rams | Norm Van Brocklin | 93%
|
| 1953 | Rams | Norm Van Brocklin | 93%
|
| 1952 | Rams | Norm Van Brocklin | 93%
|
| 1951 | Rams | Norm Van Brocklin | 93%
|
| 1950 | Rams | Norm Van Brocklin | 93%
|
| 1954 | Browns | Otto Graham | 86%
|
| 1953 | Browns | Otto Graham | 86%
|
| 1952 | Browns | Otto Graham | 86%
|
| 1951 | Browns | Otto Graham | 86%
|
| 1950 | Browns | Otto Graham | 86%
|
| 1959 | Steelers | Bobby Layne | 79%
|
| 1958 | Lions/Steelers | Bobby Layne | 79%
|
| 1956 | Lions | Bobby Layne | 79%
|
| 1953 | Lions | Bobby Layne | 79%
|
| 1952 | Lions | Bobby Layne | 79%
|
| 1951 | Lions | Bobby Layne | 79%
|
| 1951 | Redskins | Sammy Baugh | 79%
|
| 1959 | 49ers | Y. A. Tittle | 79%
|
| 1957 | 49ers | Y. A. Tittle | 79%
|
| 1954 | 49ers | Y. A. Tittle | 79%
|
| 1953 | 49ers | Y. A. Tittle | 79%
|
| 1951 | Rams | Bob Waterfield | 50%
|
| 1950 | Rams | Bob Waterfield | 50%
|
| 1956 | Giants | Charlie Conerly | 43%
|
| 1950 | Giants | Charlie Conerly | 43%
|
| 1956 | Bears | Ed Brown | 43%
|
| 1955 | Bears | Ed Brown | 43%
|
| 1956 | Packers | Tobin Rote | 43%
|
| 1958 | Rams | Bill Wade | 36%
|
| 1957 | Steelers | Earl Morrall | 36%
|
| 1958 | Redskins | Eddie LeBaron | 29%
|
| 1957 | Redskins | Eddie LeBaron | 29%
|
| 1955 | Redskins | Eddie LeBaron | 29%
|
| 1951 | Bears | Johnny Lujack | 29%
|
| 1950 | Bears | Johnny Lujack | 29%
|
| 1956 | Eagles | Bobby Thomason | 21%
|
| 1955 | Eagles | Bobby Thomason | 21%
|
| 1953 | Eagles | Bobby Thomason | 21%
|
| 1957 | Browns | Tommy O'Connell | 21%
|
| 1955 | Eagles | Adrian Burk | 14%
|
| 1954 | Eagles | Adrian Burk | 14%
|
| 1956 | Redskins | Al Dorow | 14%
|
| 1952 | Cardinals | Charley Trippi | 14%
|
| 1950 | 49ers | Frankie Albert | 14%
|
| 1950 | Redskins | Harry Gilmer | 14%
|
| 1952 | Steelers | Jim Finks | 14%
|
| 1950 | Cardinals | Jim Hardy | 14%
|