| Ranking | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| #2 | You Can Call Me Al | 94%
|
| #3 | Graceland | 78%
|
| #9 | Bridge Over Troubled Water | 73%
|
| #33 | Mrs. Robinson | 70%
|
| #7 | The Boxer | 69%
|
| #28 | Sound of Silence | 66%
|
| #6 | 50 Ways to Leave Your Lover | 64%
|
| #32 | America | 64%
|
| #4 | Kodachrome | 60%
|
| #1 | Me and Julio Down by the Schoolyard | 60%
|
| #5 | Diamonds on the Soles of Her Shoes | 55%
|
| #8 | Still Crazy After All These Years | 51%
|
| #34 | Cecilia | 48%
|
| #35 | Homeward Bound | 48%
|
| #29 | Scarborough Fair | 45%
|
| #16 | Mother and Child Reunion | 39%
|
| #13 | Slip Slidin' Away | 38%
|
| #11 | Late In The Evening | 36%
|
| #12 | The Boy In the Bubble | 36%
|
| #30 | I am A Rock | 30%
|
| #18 | Hearts and Bones | 29%
|
| #17 | The Obvious Child | 27%
|
| #14 | Loves Me Like a Rock | 25%
|
| #15 | Duncan | 23%
|
| #10 | Under African Skies | 22%
|
| #31 | April Come She Will | 21%
|
| #27 | The Only Living Boy in New York | 17%
|
| #20 | Father and Daughter | 16%
|
| #22 | Train In the Distance | 14%
|
| #19 | Something So Right | 10%
|
| #21 | Peace Like A River | 6%
|
| #26 | Peace Like a River | 6%
|
| #23 | Darling Lorraine | 1%
|
| #24 | Quality | 1%
|
| #25 | Born In Puerto Rico | 0%
|