| Character | Actor | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Jack and Judy's friend Dr. Richard Burke | Tom Selleck | 92%
|
| Phoebe's husband Mike Hannigan aka Crap Bag | Paul Rudd | 89%
|
| Ross's old highschool friend Will Colbert | Brad Pitt | 88%
|
| Ross' girlfriend Elizabeth's father | Bruce Willis | 87%
|
| Chandler's old classmate that steals his underwear | Julia Roberts | 80%
|
| Phoebe's boyfriend Ryan who gets chicken pox when on leave from the Navy | Charlie Sheen | 75%
|
| Rachel's old sorority sister Melissa Warburton | Winona Ryder | 72%
|
| Joey's hot dancer room-mate Janine La Croix | Elle MacPherson | 69%
|
| Cecilia Munroe, the acress who plays Jessica Lockhart on Days of Our Lives | Susan Sarandon | 67%
|
| Dr. Drake Ramorez's ultimate fan / stalker | Brooke Shields | 64%
|
| Tommy - The Screamer | Ben Stiller | 63%
|
| Erica, the biological mother of Monica and Chandler's twins | Anna Faris | 61%
|
| Drunk actor, Richard Crosby, that stars across from Joey in wartime film | Gary Oldman | 61%
|
| Ross and Monica's hot cousin | Denise Richards | 56%
|
| Ross and Monica's father, Jack Gellar | Elliott Gould | 56%
|
| Director Leonard Hayes that Joey impresses while needing to pee | Jeff Goldblum | 53%
|
| Monica's boyfriend Pete who tries to become an Ultimate Fighting Champion | Jon Favreau | 48%
|
| Chandler's mum and famous author of erotic fiction | Morgan Fairchild | 39%
|
| Rob Donnan, who asks Phoebe to sing for children at the library | Chris Isaak | 28%
|
| Encyclopedia salesman that visits Joey | Penn Jillette | 9%
|