| State | Date | Team | Team | Location | Final Score | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NJ | November 6, 1869 | Rutgers | Princeton | College Avenue Field, New Brunswick, New Jersey | 6–4 | 83%
|
| PA | November 11, 1876 | Penn | Princeton | Young America Cricket Club Grounds (Turnpike Bridge), Philadelphia, Pennsylvania | 6–0 | 83%
|
| AZ | November 30, 1899 | Arizona | Arizona State | Carrillo Gardens, Tucson, Arizona Territory | 11–2 | 75%
|
| AR | November 25, 1897 | Ouachita Baptist | Arkansas | Arkadelphia, Arkansas | 24–0 | 75%
|
| MA | May 14, 1874 | McGill | Harvard | Jarvis Field, Cambridge, Massachusetts | 0-3 | 75%
|
| AL | February 22, 1893 | Alabama | Auburn | Lakeview Park, Birmingham, Alabama | 22-32 | 67%
|
| FL | November 22, 1901 | Stetson | Florida Agricultural College (Florida) | North Main St. Fairgrounds, Jacksonville, Florida | 6-0 | 67%
|
| NE | February 14, 1891 | Doane | Nebraska | Field "west of the reservoir", Crete, Nebraska | 18–0 | 67%
|
| NV | November 28, 1896 | California (Junior Varsity) | Nevada | Reno, Nevada | 40–0 | 67%
|
| HI | December 25, 1920 | Hawaii | Nevada | Alexander Field, Honolulu, Hawaii Territory | 14–0 | 67%
|
| UT | November 25, 1892 | Utah State | Utah | The Quad, Logan, Utah Territory | 12–0 | 67%
|
| IA | November 16, 1889 | Grinnell | Iowa | Field on South Campus, Grinnell, Iowa | 24–0 | 58%
|
| KS | November 22, 1890 | Baker | Kansas | Baldwin City, Kansas | 22–9 | 58%
|
| MO | November 27, 1890 | Washington (MO) | Missouri | Sportsman's Park, St. Louis, Missouri | 28–0 | 58%
|
| NM | January 1, 1894 | New Mexico | New Mexico State | Albuquerque, New Mexico Territory | 18–6 | 58%
|
| TX | October 19, 1894 | Texas | Texas A&M | Hyde Park Racetrack, Austin, Texas | 38–0 | 58%
|
| WA | January 24, 1891 | Washington College | Washington | Tacoma Base Ball Park, Tacoma, Washington | 6–6 | 58%
|
| CT | November 16, 1872 | Yale | Columbia | Hamilton Park, New Haven, Connecticut | 3–0 | 50%
|
| IL | May 30, 1879 | Racine College | Michigan | White-Stocking Park, Chicago, Illinois | 0-1 | 50%
|
| MN | September 30, 1882 | Hamline | Minnesota | King's Fair Ground, Minneapolis, Minnesota | 4–0 | 50%
|
| SD | May 3, 1889 | South Dakota State | South Dakota | Sioux Falls Fairgrounds, Sioux Falls, Dakota Territory | 6–6 | 50%
|
| ID | November 18, 1894 | Idaho | Washington State | Moscow Baseball Grounds, Moscow, Idaho | 10–0 | 42%
|
| ND | November 3, 1894 | North Dakota | North Dakota State | Grand Forks, North Dakota | 24–6 | 33%
|
| LA | November 25, 1893 | LSU | Tulane | Crescent City Base Ball Park, New Orleans, Louisiana | 0-34 | 33%
|
| NH | November 17, 1881 | Amherst | Dartmouth | Hanover, New Hampshire | 0-1 | 25%
|
| VT | November 6, 1886 | Vermont | Dartmouth | Burlington, Vermont | 91–0 | 25%
|
| CO | April 11, 1885 | Colorado College | Denver | Athletic Park, Colorado Springs, Colorado | 12–0 | 25%
|
| OH | December 8, 1888 | Cincinnati | Miami (OH) | Old Main lawn, Oxford, Ohio | 0–0 | 25%
|
| TN | November 27, 1890 | Vanderbilt | Nashville | Athletic Park, Nashville, Tennessee | 40–0 | 25%
|
| OK | February 1, 1896 | Bacone | Tulsa | Muskogee, Indian Territory | Forfeit W | 25%
|
| WV | November 28, 1891 | West Virginia | Washington & Jefferson | Show Lot, Morgantown, West Virginia | 72–0 | 25%
|
| NY | November 2, 1872 | Columbia | Rutgers | Union Base Ball Club Grounds, Tremont, New York | 0–0 | 17%
|
| NC | October 18, 1888 | North Carolina | Wake Forest | State Fairgrounds, Raleigh, North Carolina | 4-6 | 17%
|
| IN | May 31, 1884 | DePauw | Butler | 7th Street Base Ball Park, Indianapolis, Indiana | 0-16 | 8%
|
| MT | November 12, 1897 | Montana | Butte Business College | Missoula, Montana | 20–4 | 8%
|
| SC | December 14, 1889 | Wofford | Furman | Encampment Grounds, Spartanburg, South Carolina | 5–1 | 8%
|
| DC | November 20, 1883 | Gallaudet | Georgetown | Kendall Green, Washington, D.C. | 13–0 | 8%
|
| GA | January 30, 1892 | Georgia | Mercer | Herty Field, Athens, Georgia | 50–0 | 8%
|
| ME | November 6, 1875 | Bates | Tufts | Rand Field, Lewiston, Maine | 1–0 | 8%
|
| RI | October 23, 1889 | Brown | Tufts | Pawtucket, Rhode Island | 16–0 | 8%
|
| KY | April 9, 1880 | Transylvania | Centre | Stoll Field, Lexington, Kentucky | 13¾–0 | 0%
|
| MD | November 30, 1882 | Navy | Johns Hopkins | Annapolis, Maryland | 8–0 | 0%
|
| AK | January 1, 1949 | Alaska–Fairbanks | Ladd Air Force Base | Fairbanks, Alaska Territory | 0–0 | 0%
|
| WI | November 29, 1888 | Racine College | Lake Forest | Racine, Wisconsin | 6–4 | 0%
|
| CA | 1889 | USC | Loyola Marymount | Los Angeles, California | 40–0 | 0%
|
| WY | November 25, 1895 | Wyoming | Northern Colorado | Prexy's Pasture, Laramie, Wyoming | 34–0 | 0%
|
| OR | November 3, 1893 | Western Oregon | Pacific (OR) | Monmouth, Oregon | 53–0 | 0%
|
| DE | October 11, 1890 | Delaware | Swarthmore (Sophomores) | Newark, Delaware | 30–0 | 0%
|
| MI | November 1, 1879 | Michigan | Toronto | Recreation Park, Detroit, Michigan | 0–0 | 0%
|
| MS | November 11, 1893 | Mississippi | Union (TN) | University Athletic Park, Oxford, Mississippi | 56–0 | 0%
|
| VA | November 2, 1873 | Washington and Lee | VMI | Lexington, Virginia | 4–2 | 0%
|