| Sport | Player | Sport Played/Experience | State | Office Held | Term | Party | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Basketball | Bill Bradley | Hall of Fame small forward at Princeton University, 1964 Olympic gold medal team, and the New York Knicks | NJ | U.S. Senator | 1979–1997 | Democratic | 70%
|
| Professional wrestling | Jesse Ventura | American Wrestling Association and World Wrestling Federation | MN | Mayor of Brooklyn Park/Governor of Minnesota | 1991–1995/1999-2003 | Independence | 60%
|
| Football | Gerald Ford | Center, linebacker, and long snapper for University of Michigan, 1932–1935, assistant varsity football coach for Yale University, 1935–1937, junior varsity head football coach for Yale University, 1938[1] | MI | U.S. Representative/Vice President/President | 1949–1973/1973-1974/1974-1977 | Republican | 50%
|
| Bodybuilding | Arnold Schwarzenegger | Mr. Olympia from 1970 to 1973 | CA | Governor | 2003–2011 | Republican | 40%
|
| Basketball | Dave Bing | Hall of Fame shooting guard at Syracuse University and three NBA teams, including the Detroit Pistons | MI | Mayor of Detroit | 2009–2013 | Democratic | 40%
|
| Football | Jack Kemp | Played quarterback for the Buffalo Bills, 1962–69 | NY | U.S. Representative | 1971–1989 | Republican | 40%
|
| Basketball | Kevin Johnson | University of California, Berkeley, 1983–1987; Cleveland Cavaliers and Phoenix Suns, 1987–2000 | CA | Mayor of Sacramento | 2008–2016 | Democratic | 40%
|
| Football | Steve Largent | Hall of Fame wide receiver for the Seattle Seahawks, 1976–89 | OK | U.S. Representative | 1995–2003 | Republican | 40%
|
| Football | Alan Page | Played for University of Notre Dame and the Minnesota Vikings | MN | Associate Justice of the State Supreme Court | 1993–2015 | Independent | 20%
|
| Football | Anthony Gonzalez | Ohio State University, Indianapolis Colts and New England Patriots | OH | U.S. Representative | 2019–2023 | Republican | 20%
|
| Baseball | Jim Bunning | Hall of Fame pitcher with the Detroit Tigers, Philadelphia Phillies, Pittsburgh Pirates, and Los Angeles Dodgers | KY | U.S. Representative/U.S. Senator | 1987–1999/1999-2011 | Republican | 20%
|
| Running | Jim Ryun | The last American to hold the world record in the mile run, competitor in the 1964, 1968, and 1972 Summer Olympics, first high schooler to break the four-minute mile | KS | U.S. Representative | 1996–2007 | Republican | 20%
|
| Basketball | Maura Healey | Professional and collegiate women's basketball player | MA | Attorney General of Massachusetts/Governor of Massachusetts | 2015–2023/2023-present | Democratic | 20%
|
| Football | Tommy Tuberville | Played for Southern Arkansas University; assistant coach at Arkansas State University, the University of Miami, and Texas A&M University; head coach at the University of Mississippi, Auburn University, Texas Tech University, and the University of Cincinnati | AL | U.S. Senator | 2021–present | Republican | 20%
|
| Football | Tom Osborne | Head football coach for the University of Nebraska, 1973–97; University of Nebraska athletic director, 2007–2013 | NE | U.S. Representative | 2001–2007 | Republican | 20%
|
| Judo | Ben Nighthorse Campbell | Captain of the US team at the 1964 Summer Olympics | CO | State Representative/U.S. Representative/U.S. Senator | 1983–1987/1987-1993/1993-2005 | Democratic (before 1995)/Republican (1995–present) | 10%
|
| Football | Colin Allred | Played for the Tennessee Titans | TX | U.S. Representative | 2019–2025 | Democratic | 10%
|
| Professional wrestling | Glenn Jacobs | Independent circuit (1992–1995) and in WWE (1995–present), most notably as Kane. Also played football and basketball at Northeast Missouri State University (now Truman State University). | TN | Mayor of Knox County | 2018–present | Republican | 10%
|
| Football | Heath Shuler | Played for the University of Tennessee and the New Orleans Saints and Oakland Raiders | NC | U.S. Representative | 2007–2013 | Democratic | 10%
|
| Football | Jon Runyan Sr. | Offensive tackle for University of Michigan, and in the NFL for the Tennessee Titans (1996–99), Philadelphia Eagles (2000–08), and San Diego Chargers (2009) | NJ | U.S. Representative | 2011–2015 | Republican | 10%
|
| Mixed martial arts | Sharice Davids | Fought professionally, 2013–2014 | KS | U.S. Representative | 2018–present | Democratic | 10%
|
| Ice hockey | Brandon Bochenski | Played wing for the University of North Dakota and several AHL and NHL teams | ND | Mayor of Grand Forks | 2020–present | Republican | 0%
|
| Football | Burgess Owens | Safety for the University of Miami (1970–72), New York Jets (1973–79), and Oakland Raiders (1980–82) | UT | U.S. Representative | 2021–present | Republican | 0%
|
| Football | Dwayne Woodruff | Cornerback with the Pittsburgh Steelers (1979–1990) | PA | Judge of the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas | 2005–present | Independent | 0%
|
| Football | Edward J. King | Guard and Defensive end for the Buffalo Bills and Baltimore Colts | MA | Governor of Massachusetts | 1979–1983 | Democratic | 0%
|
| Football | Fob James | All-American halfback for Auburn University, 1952–1955 and Montreal Alouettes, 1956 | AL | Governor of Alabama | 1979–1983/1995-1999 | Democratic/Republican | 0%
|
| Baseball | Frank White | World Series champion who played for the Kansas City Royals for 18 years. | MO | Member of the Jackson County Legislature/Executive of Jackson County | 2014–2016/2016-2025 | Democratic | 0%
|
| Football | Greg Lashutka | Played college football for Ohio State, drafted into the NFL by the Buffalo Bills | OH | Mayor of Columbus | 1992–2000 | Republican | 0%
|
| Football | J. C. Watts | Played for University of Oklahoma and the Ottawa Rough Riders | OK | U.S. Representative | 1995–2003 | Republican | 0%
|
| Football | Jim Schwantz | Linebacker for Purdue University, and in the NFL for the Chicago Bears, Dallas Cowboys, and San Francisco 49ers | IL | Mayor of Palatine | 2009–present | Independent | 0%
|
| Football | Jim Tressel | Played for Baldwin Wallace University; assistant coach at University of Akron, Miami University, Syracuse University, and the Ohio State University; head coach at Youngstown State University and the Ohio State University | OH | Lieutenant Governor of Ohio | 2025–present | Republican | 0%
|
| Football | Napoleon Harris | Collegiate and professional linebacker, played for Northwestern and four NFL teams | IL | Member of the Illinois Senate | 2013–present | Democratic | 0%
|
| Basketball | Raymond Flynn | Professional and collegiate men's basketball player | MA | Member of the Massachusetts House of Representatives/Mayor of Boston | 1971–1975 and 1975–1978/1984-1993 | Democratic | 0%
|
| Football | Robert R. Thomas | NFL kicker | IL | Judge of the circuit court of DuPage County/Justice of the Illinois Supreme Court/Chief Justice of Illinois Supreme Court | 1988–1994/2000-2020/2005-2008 | Republican | 0%
|
| Basketball | Tom McMillen | Played for the University of Maryland and the Buffalo Braves, New York Knicks, Atlanta Hawks, and Washington Bullets | MD | U.S. Representative | 1987–1993 | Democratic | 0%
|