| Nickname | Tenure | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Polar Bear | 2019– | Pete Alonso | 96%
|
| Tom Terrific / The Franchise | 1967–1977 1983 | Tom Seaver | 96%
|
| Doc | 1984–1994 | Dwight Gooden | 95%
|
| Straw | 1983–1990 | Darryl Strawberry | 92%
|
| Pizza Man | 1998–2005 | Mike Piazza | 90%
|
| Captain America / D-Dub | 2004–2016 2018 | David Wright | 86%
|
| Mookie | 1980–1989 | William "Mookie" Wilson | 84%
|
| Mr. Smile | 2021– | Francisco Lindor | 81%
|
| Thor | 2015–2021 | Noah Syndergaard | 73%
|
| HoJo | 1985–1993 | Howard Johnson | 70%
|
| Fonzie | 1995–2002 | Edgardo Alfonzo | 50%
|
| Kid | 1985–1989 | Gary Carter | 50%
|
| Mex | 1983–1989 | Keith Hernandez | 46%
|
| Maz / The Italian Stallion | 1976–1981 1986–1989 | Lee Mazzilli | 36%
|
| Nails | 1985–1989 | Lenny Dykstra | 36%
|