| WAR | Years | Position | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 142.6 | 1954–1974 | OF | Hank Aaron | 96%
|
| 85.3 | 1993, 1995–2012 | 3B | Chipper Jones | 95%
|
| 61.0 | 1996–2007 | OF | Andruw Jones | 94%
|
| 67.3 | 1993–2003 | P | Greg Maddux | 94%
|
| 69.5 | 1988–1999, 2001–2008 | P | John Smoltz | 89%
|
| 63.6 | 1987–2002, 2008 | P | Tom Glavine | 88%
|
| 94.0 | 1952–1966 | 3B | Eddie Mathews | 66%
|
| 99.3 | 1942, 1946–1964 | P | Warren Spahn | 66%
|
| 47.3 | 1976–1990 | OF | Dale Murphy | 62%
|
| 88.5 | 1964–1983 | P | Phil Niekro | 60%
|