| The first MLB player to | Year | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| hit 60 home runs in a season | 1927 | Babe Ruth | 100%
|
| win the Home Run Derby as a rookie | 2017 | Aaron Judge | 86%
|
| be intentionally walked 100+ times in a season | 2004 | Barry Bonds | 86%
|
| start the All-Star Game as a rookie pitcher | 2024 | Paul Skenes | 86%
|
| steal 100 bases in a season | 1982 | Rickey Henderson | 86%
|
| hit 60 home runs in a season while playing catcher | 2025 | Cal Raleigh | 71%
|
| hit 50 home runs as a rookie | 2019 | Pete Alonso | 71%
|
| hit 40+ home runs and steal 70+ bases in a season | 2023 | Ronald Acuña Jr. | 71%
|
| record a 50–50 season | 2024 | Shohei Ohtani | 71%
|
| reach 4000 hits | 1921 | Ty Cobb | 71%
|
| hit a walk-off home run in Game 7 of the World Series | 1960 | Bill Mazeroski | 57%
|
| hit 70 home runs in a season | 1998 | Mark McGwire | 57%
|
| win 7 Cy Young Awards | 2004 | Roger Clemens | 57%
|
| win MVP in both the AL and NL | 1966 | Frank Robinson | 29%
|
| reach the 40–40 club | 1988 | José Canseco | 29%
|
| record 300 saves | 1978 | Rollie Fingers | 29%
|
| hit a home run in five consecutive postseason games | 2017 | George Springer | 14%
|
| win the Home Run Derby | 1985 | Dave Parker | 0%
|
| win Rookie of the Year and MVP in the same season | 1975 | Fred Lynn | 0%
|
| throw a no-hitter | 1876 | George Bradley | 0%
|