| Number | Years | Pos | Team | Player Name | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 | 1914 - 1935 | OF/P | Yankees | Babe Ruth | 95%
|
| 22 | 2008 - 2025 | P | Dodgers | Clayton Kershaw | 85%
|
| 1 | 1978 - 1996 | SS | Cardinals | Ozzie Smith | 85%
|
| 99 | 2016 - | RF | Yankees | Aaron Judge | 80%
|
| 31 | 1986 - 2008 | P | Braves | Greg Maddux | 80%
|
| 5 | 2001 - 2022 | 1B/LF/3B | Cardinals | Albert Pujols | 75%
|
| 13 | 1994 - 2016 | SS/3B | Yankees | Alex Rodriguez | 75%
|
| 25 | 1986 - 2007 | LF | Giants | Barry Bonds | 75%
|
| 27 | 2011 - | CF | Angels | Mike Trout | 75%
|
| 9 | 1939 - 1960 | LF | Red Sox | Ted Williams | 75%
|
| 29 | 1998 - 2018 | 3B | Rangers | Adrian Beltre | 70%
|
| 20 | 1956 - 1976 | OF/1B | Reds | Frank Robinson | 70%
|
| 44 | 1954 - 1976 | RF - 1B | Braves | Hank Aaron | 70%
|
| 7 | 1951 - 1968 | CF/1B | Yankees | Mickey Mantle | 70%
|
| 42 | 1945 - 1956 | 2B/3B/1B | Dodgers | Jackie Robinson | 65%
|
| 14 | 1963 - 1986 | OF/1B/3B | Reds | Pete Rose | 65%
|
| 51 | 1988 - 2009 | P | Mariners | Randy Johnson | 65%
|
| 6 | 1941 - 1963 | OF/1B | Cardinals | Stan Musial | 65%
|
| 24 | 1951 - 1973 | CF | Giants | Willie Mays | 65%
|
| 33 | 1988 - 2005 | RF/1B | Rockies | Larry Walker | 60%
|
| 34 | 1966 - 1993 | P | Astros | Nolan Ryan | 60%
|
| 19 | 1974 - 1993 | SS/CF | Brewers | Robin Yount | 60%
|
| 8 | 1963 - 1984 | 2B | Reds | Joe Morgan | 55%
|
| 50 | 2014 - | RF/SS/2B | Dodgers | Mookie Betts | 55%
|
| 12 | 1988 - 2004 | 2B | Blue Jays | Roberto Alomar | 55%
|
| 26 | 1982 - 1999 | 3B | Red Sox | Wade Boggs | 55%
|
| 17 | 1997 - 2013 | 1B | Rockies | Todd Helton | 50%
|
| 47 | 1987 - 2008 | P | Braves | Tom Glavine | 50%
|
| 41 | 1967 - 1986 | P | Mets | Tom Seaver | 50%
|
| 23 | 2004 - 2023 | P | Royals | Zack Greinke | 50%
|
| 46 | 1995 - 2013 | P | Yankees | Andy Pettitte | 45%
|
| 45 | 1959 - 1975 | P | Cardinals | Bob Gibson | 45%
|
| 52 | 2001 - 2019 | P | Yankees | C.C. Sabathia | 45%
|
| 38 | 1988 - 2007 | P | Phillies | Curt Schilling | 45%
|
| 43 | 1975 - 1998 | P | A's | Dennis Eckersley | 45%
|
| 28 | 1970 - 1992 | P | Twins | Bert Blyleven | 40%
|
| 72 | 1969 - 1993 | C | White Sox | Carlton Fisk | 35%
|
| 57 | 2000 - 2012 | P | Twins | Johan Santana | 35%
|
| 35 | 1963 -1987 | P | Braves | Phil Niekro | 35%
|
| 4 | 1915 - 1937 | 2B/IF | Cardinals | Rogers Hornsby | 35%
|
| 30 | 1979 - 2002 | LF | Expos | Tim Raines | 35%
|
| 36 | 1962 - 1983 | P | Giants | Gaylord Perry | 30%
|
| 32 | 1965 - 1988 | P | Phillies | Steve Carlton | 30%
|
| 2 | 1924 - 1942 | 2B | Tigers | Charlie Gehringer | 25%
|
| 53 | 1956 - 1969 | P | Dodgers | Don Drysdale | 25%
|
| 37 | 1974 - 1990 | 1B | Cardinals | Keith Hernandez | 25%
|
| 10 | 1925 - 1941 | P | Red Sox | Lefty Grove | 25%
|
| 56 | 2000 - 2015 | P | White Sox | Mark Buehrle | 25%
|
| 55 | 1983 - 2000 | P | Dodgers | Orel Hershiser | 25%
|
| 54 | 1972 - 1994 | P | Yankees | Goose Gossage | 20%
|
| 49 | 1975 - 1988 | P | Yankees | Ron Guidry | 20%
|
| 40 | 1997 - 2018 | P | Indians | Bartolo Colon | 15%
|
| 11 | 1926 - 1945 | RF | Pirates | Paul Waner | 15%
|
| 39 | 1937 - 1957 | C/OF | Dodgers | Roy Campanella | 15%
|
| 16 | 1923 - 1946 | P | White Sox | Ted Lyons | 15%
|
| 21 | 1984 - 2007 | P | Red Sox | Roger Clemons | 10%
|
| 18 | 1914 - 1933 | P | White Sox | Red Faber | 5%
|
| 15 | 1998 - 2017 | CF | Mets | Carlos Beltan | 0%
|