| Hint | Answer | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Founding father is shot by best friend | Hamilton | 85%
|
| Bloke finds weird plant. Becomes famous. Kills everyone else with plant | Little Shop of Horrors | 79%
|
| Farm girl's house falls on old lady. Teams up with people who are missing organs to kill old lady's sister. | The Wizard of Oz | 78%
|
| Like Romeo and Juliet, but Juliet is poor and speaks Spanish | West Side Story | 73%
|
| Like ^, but different main characters | Wicked | 72%
|
| Bored woman cheats on dumb husband. Tries to get weird bloke to pretend she didn't shoot her boyfriend | Chicago | 66%
|
| Depressed teenager pretends he is gay for a dead guy in order to make himself not be invisible | Dear Evan Hansen | 66%
|
| Doppelgänger cuts people's hair, then makes pie out of them | Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street | 65%
|
| Depressed banker hires a lady on drugs to give his kids weird hallucinations | Mary Poppins | 48%
|
| In strange world, only one furry character is allowed to go to heaven | Cats | 47%
|
| Bloke is sad because he cannot pee. Gets thrown off building for loving president's daughter | Urinetown | 34%
|
| Bloke drinks Mountain Dew in order to become more popular. Instead becomes less popular | Be More Chill | 33%
|
| Poor bloke is addicted to reprimanding his daughters for who they like | Fiddler on the Roof | 25%
|
| Unusually colored bloke is ordered by short guy to fall in love with shape-shifter | Shrek The Musical | 22%
|
| An academic event that should not take very long is repeatedly interrupted by kids singing | The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee | 20%
|
| Banker illegally gets on boat. Falls in love with girl married to British guy. Pretends to be gangster. | Anything Goes | 12%
|
| Songwriter has the bright idea to make girl cheat on boyfriend on TV | Bye Bye Birdie | 4%
|