| Chief justice | Appointed by | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| John Roberts | George Bush the Younger | 100%
|
| Warren E. Burger | Richard Nixon | 97%
|
| Roger B. Taney | Andrew Jackson | 93%
|
| Earl Warren | Dwight D. Eisenhower | 93%
|
| Harlan F. Stone | Franklin D. Roosevelt | 93%
|
| John Jay | George Washington | 93%
|
| John Marshall | John Adams | 93%
|
| William Rehnquist | Ronald Reagan | 93%
|
| Salmon P. Chase | Abraham Lincoln | 90%
|
| Fred M. Vinson | Harry S Truman | 83%
|
| Charles Evans Hughes | Herbert Hoover | 83%
|
| William Howard Taft | Warren G. Harding | 79%
|
| Edward Douglass White | William Howard Taft | 72%
|
| Morrison Waite | Ulysses S. Grant | 69%
|
| Melville Fuller | Grover Cleveland | 66%
|