| Actors | Hint | Character | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Laurence Olivier; Liam Neeson | god | Zeus | 80%
|
| Halle Berry; Alexandra Shipp* | mutant | Storm | 78%
|
| Jared Leto*; Zach Galifianakis* | villain | The Joker | 69%
|
| Dustin Hoffman; Garrett Hedlund* | pirate | Hook | 58%
|
| James Marsden; Tye Sheridan* | mutant | Cyclops | 57%
|
| Famke Janssen; Sophie Turner* | mutant | Jean Grey | 55%
|
| Robert Englund; Jackie Earle Haley | child killer | Freddy Krueger | 54%
|
| Alec Guinness; Bruno Ganz | dictator | Adolf Hitler | 52%
|
| Kris Kristofferson; Emilio Estevez | outlaw | Billy the Kid | 47%
|
| Steve McQueen; Pierce Brosnan | art thief | Thomas Crowne | 45%
|
| James Woods; Ralph Fiennes | god | Hades | 44%
|
| Arnold Schwarzenegger; Kevin Sorbo | hero | Hercules | 41%
|
| David Janssen; Harrison Ford | fugitive | Dr. Richard Kimble | 40%
|
| Kiefer Sutherland; John Malkovich | musketeer | Athos | 36%
|
| Anthony Michael Hall; Ed Helms* | vacationer | Russell Griswold | 24%
|
| Sarah Michelle Gellar; Emilia Clarke | mother | Sarah Connor | 23%
|
| David Doyle; Bill Murray | liaison | John Bosley | 10%
|
| Anthony Perkins; John Malkovich | doctor | Dr. Jekyll | 7%
|
| Peter Firth; Daniel Radcliffe | horse blinder | Alan Strang | 3%
|
| John Lithgow; Dennis Quaid | reverened | Shaw Moore | 2%
|