| Club | Main rival | % of votes | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arsenal | Tottenham Hotspur | 87% | 97%
|
| Aston Villa | Birmingham City | 76% | 82%
|
| Birmingham City | Aston Villa | 89% | 79%
|
| Everton | Liverpool | 86% | 78%
|
| Liverpool | Manchester United | 84% | 75%
|
| Manchester United | Liverpool | 88% | 73%
|
| Cardiff City | Swansea City | 76% | 73%
|
| Bristol City | Bristol Rovers | 83% | 70%
|
| Bristol Rovers | Bristol City | 77% | 69%
|
| Brighton & Hove Albion | Crystal Palace | 85% | 64%
|
| Bournemouth | Southampton | 79% | 61%
|
| Blackburn Rovers | Burnley | 82% | 60%
|
| Newcastle United | Sunderland | 72% | 60%
|
| Burnley | Blackburn Rovers | 84% | 58%
|
| Leeds United | Manchester United | 81% | 57%
|
| Crystal Palace | Brighton & Hove Albion | 77% | 55%
|
| Ipswich Town | Norwich City | 81% | 55%
|
| Portsmouth | Southampton | 91% | 55%
|
| Sheffield United | Sheffield Wednesday | 83% | 54%
|
| Tottenham Hotspur | Arsenal | 87% | 52%
|
| AFC Wimbledon | Milton Keynes Dons | 82% | 52%
|
| Sheffield Wednesday | Sheffield United | 85% | 52%
|
| Millwall | West Ham United | 80% | 51%
|
| Norwich City | Ipswich Town | 70% | 48%
|
| Manchester City | Liverpool | 79% | 48%
|
| Southampton | Portsmouth | 91% | 48%
|
| Bradford City | Leeds United | 83% | 46%
|
| Sunderland | Newcastle United | 89% | 46%
|
| Derby County | Nottingham Forest | 88% | 46%
|
| Nottingham Forest | Derby County | 77% | 45%
|
| Exeter City | Plymouth Argyle | 93% | 43%
|
| Plymouth Argyle | Exeter City | 83% | 40%
|
| Blackpool | Preston North End | 90% | 40%
|
| Port Vale | Stoke City | 92% | 39%
|
| Newport County | Cardiff City | 77% | 34%
|
| Charlton Athletic | Millwall | 82% | 34%
|
| Middlesbrough | Sunderland | 77% | 34%
|
| Huddersfield Town | Leeds United | 78% | 33%
|
| Milton Keynes Dons | AFC Wimbledon | 72% | 31%
|
| Fleetwood Town | Blackpool | 73% | 31%
|
| Leicester City | Nottingham Forest | 72% | 31%
|
| Wolverhampton Wanderers | West Bromwich Albion | 72% | 31%
|
| Hull City | Leeds United | 72% | 30%
|
| Colchester United | Southend United | 86% | 30%
|
| West Bromwich Albion | Wolverhampton Wanderers | 81% | 30%
|
| Preston North End | Blackpool | 79% | 28%
|
| Cambridge United | Peterborough United | 87% | 27%
|
| Barnsley | Sheffield Wednesday | 77% | 27%
|
| West Ham United | Tottenham Hotspur | 82% | 27%
|
| Forest Green Rovers | Cheltenham Town | 89% | 25%
|
| Stoke City | Port Vale | 52% | 25%
|
| Bolton Wanderers | Manchester United | 74% | 24%
|
| Doncaster Rovers | Rotherham United | 71% | 24%
|
| Cheltenham Town | Forest Green Rovers | 82% | 22%
|
| Grimsby Town | Hull City | 86% | 22%
|
| Oxford United | Swindon Town | 74% | 21%
|
| Leyton Orient | West Ham United | 80% | 21%
|
| Coventry City | Aston Villa | 75% | 18%
|
| Southend United | Colchester United | 83% | 18%
|
| Accrington Stanley | Morecambe | 66% | 18%
|
| Wigan Athletic | Bolton Wanderers | 74% | 16%
|
| Rochdale | Bury | 74% | 16%
|
| Lincoln City | Grimsby Town | 65% | 16%
|
| Bury | Bolton Wanderers | 73% | 15%
|
| Scunthorpe United | Grimsby Town | 85% | 15%
|
| Gillingham | Millwall | 69% | 15%
|
| Peterborough United | Northampton Town | 76% | 15%
|
| Crewe Alexandra | Port Vale | 88% | 15%
|
| Rotherham United | Doncaster Rovers | 76% | 13%
|
| Oldham Athletic | Manchester United | 71% | 13%
|
| Swindon Town | Oxford United | 75% | 13%
|
| Northampton Town | Peterborough United | 79% | 13%
|
| Burton Albion | Port Vale | 64% | 13%
|
| Reading | Swindon Town | 74% | 13%
|
| Morecambe | Accrington Stanley | 89% | 12%
|
| Macclesfield Town | Crewe Alexandra | 77% | 12%
|
| Crawley Town | AFC Wimbledon | 71% | 6%
|
| Salford City | Oldham Athletic | 44% | 6%
|
| Shrewsbury Town | Walsall | 75% | 6%
|
| Tranmere Rovers | Bolton Wanderers | 63% | 4%
|
| Wycombe Wanderers | Colchester United | 76% | 4%
|
| Mansfield Town | Lincoln City | 52% | 4%
|
| Carlisle United | Middlesbrough | 69% | 4%
|
| Stevenage | Milton Keynes Dons | 89% | 3%
|
| Walsall | West Bromwich Albion | 72% | 3%
|