| Plot | Song | % Correct |
|---|---|---|
| Chronicle of America in the 50s and 60s before the music died | American Pie | 74%
|
| He got in one little fight and his scared mom sent him to live in California | Fresh Prince Theme Song | 60%
|
| Young man is ruined by a New Orleans house of ill repute | House of the Rising Sun | 56%
|
| Major Tom goes to space; doesn't make it home | Space Oddity | 55%
|
| Guy writes fan letters; doesn't get responses; has major psychotic break | Stan | 51%
|
| Satan has a fiddle battle with a boy named Johnny | The Devil Went down to Georgia | 49%
|
| Tough man with a girly name tries to find his dad so he can kill him | A Boy Named Sue | 48%
|
| Dad can't spend time with son; Son grows and can't spend time with Dad | Cat's in the Cradle | 45%
|
| Man tired of his wife unknowingly answers wife's personal ad | Escape (The Pina Colada Song) | 38%
|
| Guy on a train gets advice from a dying old card shark | The Gambler | 29%
|
| Young teacher falls in love with a girl half his age | Don't Stand so Close to Me | 27%
|
| Massive freighter sinks in Lake Superior during a November storm | Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald | 24%
|
| A demon is defeated by the greatest song in the world | Tribute | 23%
|
| A boxer, who coulda been champion, is wrongfully convicted of murder | Hurricane | 20%
|
| Band goes to Switzerland to make a record; witness a big fire | Smoke on the Water | 19%
|
| Billy Joe & Bobbie Sue rob a man; Persued by detective Billy Mack | Take the Money and Run | 15%
|
| South Dakota man attempts to shoot off the legs of his rival; finds a bible | Rocky Raccoon | 13%
|
| Sister secretly kills brother's cheating wife and friend; brother is hanged | The Night the Lights Went out in Georgia | 9%
|
| Guy gets arrested for littering and therefore can't get in the army | Alice's Restaurant | 7%
|
| Cheating wife hides her lover in her closet when husband comes home | Trapped in the Closet | 7%
|