| Location | Population | Island | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| New York | 7,568,304 | Long Island | 94%
|
| New York | 1,537,195 | Manhattan | 94%
|
| New York | 443,728 | Staten Island | 94%
|
| Hawaii | 953,207 | Oahu | 88%
|
| Hawaii | 185,079 | Hawaii (Big Island) | 75%
|
| Hawaii | 144,444 | Maui | 75%
|
| Guam | 154,805 | Guam | 69%
|
| Florida | 24,649 | Key West | 63%
|
| Hawaii | 67,091 | Kaua'i | 56%
|
| Puerto Rico | 3,725,789 | Puerto Rico | 50%
|
| Northern Mariana Islands | 62,392 | Saipan | 50%
|
| Texas | 58,175 | Galveston Island | 44%
|
| Florida | 87,779 | Miami Beach | 44%
|
| US Virgin Islands | 53,234 | Saint Croix | 44%
|
| US Virgin Islands | 51,181 | Saint Thomas | 44%
|
| South Carolina | 33,862 | Hilton Head Island | 38%
|
| Massachusetts | 10,172 | Nantucket Island | 38%
|
| Alaska | 13,592 | Kodiak Island | 31%
|
| Massachusetts | 14,901 | Martha's Vineyard | 31%
|
| California | 73,812 | Alameda Island | 25%
|
| New Jersey | 57,457 | Absecon Island | 19%
|
| Florida | 12,344 | Key Biscayne | 19%
|
| Rhode Island | 60,870 | Rhode Island | 19%
|
| Washington | 58,211 | Whidbey Island | 19%
|
| Washington | 20,308 | Bainbridge Island | 13%
|
| South Carolina | 11,477 | Johns Island | 13%
|
| New York | 18,621 | Grand Island | 6%
|
| South Carolina | 33,781 | James Island | 6%
|
| New Jersey | ~20,000 | Long Beach Island | 6%
|
| Florida | 16,413 | Marco Island | 6%
|
| Maine | 10,424 | Mount Desert Island | 6%
|
| New York | 11,661 | Roosevelt Island | 6%
|
| Georgia | 12,743 | St. Simons Island | 6%
|
| American Samoa | 55,876 | Tutuila | 6%
|
| Georgia | 15,138 | Wilmington Island | 6%
|
| Washington | 13,358 | Camano Island | 0%
|
| Maryland | 16,812 | Kent Island | 0%
|
| South Carolina | 12,570 | Ladys Island | 0%
|
| Florida | 10,468 | Palm Beach | 0%
|
| Alaska | 13,477 | Revillagigedo Island | 0%
|
| Washington | 10,123 | Vashon Island | 0%
|