| Club | Period | Player | % Correct |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bayern Munich | 1964-1979 | Gerd Müller | 86%
|
| Manchester United | 1991-2014 | Ryan Giggs | 75%
|
| Manchester United | 1992-2011 | Gary Neville | 72%
|
| Manchester United | 1994-2013 | Paul Scholes | 69%
|
| Benfica | 1960-1975 | Eusébio | 61%
|
| Bayern Munich | 2002-2017 | Philipp Lahm | 61%
|
| Manchester United | 1956-1973 | Bobby Charlton | 53%
|
| Bayern Munich | 1994-2008 | Oliver Kahn | 53%
|
| Bayern Munich | 1964-1977 | Franz Beckenbauer | 52%
|
| Arsenal FC | 1983-2002 | Tony Adams | 47%
|
| Southampton | 1986-2002 | Matthew Le Tissier | 45%
|
| Arsenal FC | 1990-2003 | David Seaman | 33%
|
| Bayern Munich | 2002-2015 | Bastian Schweinsteiger | 28%
|
| Bayern Munich | 1962-1979 | Sepp Maier | 13%
|
| Bayern Munich | 1992-2007 | Mehmet Scholl | 10%
|
| 1. FC Köln | 1972-1987 | Harald Schumacher | 8%
|
| 1. FC Köln | 1962-1977 | Wolfgang Overath | 8%
|
| Borussia Mönchengladbach | 1965-1979 | Berti Vogts | 7%
|
| Sampdoria | 1982-1997 | Roberto Mancini | 7%
|
| Benfica | 1967-1986 | Nené | 2%
|