Where does it say it's a list of every single famous French person? IF you don't like the list... write your own quiz. (Then watch everyone else come in and criticise it.)
He's definitely one of the most famous (most published author in the world I believe??) but even as a fan of his I'm not sure I'd describe him as 'relevant'
A important author, one of my favourites as a kid, too but his legacy doesn't compare to that of other authors or philosophers, some of which were mentioned in this very quiz (Rousseau, Voltaire, Montesquieu, Victor Hugo, Proust, etc.)
I was in Poland this summer, and it was obvious that they are very proud of Marie Curie (along with Copernicus and Chopin). I can imagine some hurt feelings there when you make her French.
I was just about to say the same. My Polish ex gf would turn in her grave if she heard someone was calling Curie Polish. (Not that my ex is dead on anything.) :)
Chopin's father was french himself. Poland can totally be proud of Marie Curie, but at the time coming in France was her only way to work as a physicist.
As they should be. She was still French, though. She certainly kept hold of her Polish heritage (the first element she discovered was Polonium, named after Poland), but she was also a naturalised French citizen and she was buried in France as a French hero (in a lead casket, I hope). I expect when I'm famous and appearing on JetPunk quizzes there will arguments about whether I'm British or Australian. For the record, I'm Australian, but I have no problem with the British worshiping me as well.
Why was drunken gandalf purged? I know that he did not author any quizzes. And he might have been inactive for a year. But I thought the rule was that you had to fit both of those criteria and also be below a certain level like level 5 or 15 or something.
Chopin, like Curie, is also Polish. Agree with Ozchris that the list had no pretensions to being exhaustive, thus complaints about left out figures should be a moot point. But still...no Proust? Arguably, he wrote the greatest work of literature in any language...
Very simple: As soon as she married Pierre Curie she became french, before her wedding she was polish and her name was Maria Skłodowska. If you call her Marie Curie she is french.
THANK YOU SO MUCH for asking the proper spelling for "De Gaulle" and not leaving me (again) with the last "LE" in the box that I need to erase! It annoys me every time. It's not like it's a difficult name to spell, and not like there are any alternate spellings, either. I completely blanked out on Robespierre. For some reason I can never remember his name. And I think I tried every Merovingian king name I cold remember (Childebert,Childeric, Dagobert...) but somehow never remembered Clovis. Lol!
He was born and raised in rural France. At 18 he moved to Paris and started wrestling, only moving to Canada when he was 25. You can make an argument that he was Canadian (though I can't find any evidence that he ever became a naturalized Canadian citizen), but you definitely can't argue that he isn't French.
Thanks for this quiz. As a french woman, I'll be very proud if Marie Curie was french... but she wasn't. You can replace her with her husband Pierre maybe (they both work hard!)
when you get the french nationality, you are french. Other consideration would be insulting. She was both polish and french and apparently it was much easier for her to deal with than it is for you.
Well maybe they should dig her out of the Pantheon. Broaden your mind! You're not forever tied to the piece of soil where you were born. Marie Curie is Polish AND French.
She was Polish and proud of that. She donated radium for Polish institutes, she helped polish politicians fighting for our independence. She underlined her Polish heritage. Simply marrying someone of a different nationality, obtaining citizenship and working there does not make someone a different person.
I'm not much of a sports fan - and definitely not a wrestling fan - but I've always loved the story that, when Andre the Giant was a kid, Samuel Beckett used to drive him to school in a jeep because he was too big to fit inside the schoolbus.
Since Beckett was a protegee of James Joyce, we now have a direct line of mentorship from Joyce to Andre. I find that delightful.
Karl the Great (Charlemagne) and Chlodovech (Clovis) weren't French, they were Frankish. The Franks were actually a tribe of Germans, unrelated to the French.
... You should check your facts, or at least your conclusions. Historically, France is partly a germanic country. Charlemagne being a monarch in the history of several modern countries, France and Germany included. Why do you think France is called France?
Kalbo: that is a truly hilarious line. I have literally laughed so hard that I have ruptured all of my internal organs. It is the greatest privilege known to humanity to experience your stunning wit.
Nice quiz, but I second all the comments complaining about regarding Maria Skłodowska-Curie as French. There have been many French scientists or other famous persons to choose from.
Nevertheless, check put my "Famous Polish people" quiz: http://www.jetpunk.com/user-quizzes/97363/famous-poles
I'm French and was really surprised to see Andre the Giant in this list. I know him (Princess Bride !) but he is not that famous in France.
I didn't get Pasteur. He is mostly known for the discovery of the first vaccine against rabies. But then, I guess I didn't used my brain to wonder where does "pasteurization" comes from...
So funny to see people arguing about Marie Curie :D In France, we consider her Polish AND French.
Because she WAS Polish and French. The number of people who are trying to insist that dual citizenship doesn't exist is quite shocking to me. I wonder at their motives.
I don't think their motives are sinister: commenters here are hugely into trivia quizzes, so we very much want everything to fit neatly into exactly one category, and we get upset when reality spoils the elegance of our quiz themes.
Funnily enough I suspect there's some truth in that. It's a very odd list, from a European perspective - no Moliere, no Racine, no film stars, no singers. But it may well be a fair reflection of which French people are most famous in the States.
We're coming up on Moliere's 400th birthday in a couple of days. And sure, a few film stars would be nice (Belmondo and Bardot for instance) but I have no problem with a list of people who are more famous internationally than domestically.
Indeed as this is a US site and Quizmaster is American, it is very US centric indeed in terms of POV. I am not even French but nobody cares about Andre the Giant outside the US, and not including people like Alain Delon, Edith Piaf or Blaise Pascal instead of odd ones like Clovis, Guetta and Flaubert does seem off. I am surpised he included Zizou though, I bet he is totally unkown in the US
I'm French, and i think this quiz is wonderful, but i think for zidane "zizou" should be accepted as an answer, and as I am from Normandy and lived my entire life with a view over the church where william the conqueror is burried, I am pretty confident when I say "Guillaume le conquérant" should be accepted as an answer
Wow, first person to take the quiz since the update - I beat 100% of test takers and all the answers I didn't get are clearly impossible because 0% of takers got them!
I tried the animal name for the penultimate answer, because that's the kind of fun fact we learn in English classes in France (instead of learning how to speak English properly, but that's another story). I didn't expect it to be valid. I have never known if it was really something or just an anecdote.
More generally, thank you for the type-ins allowing the French spellings when they differ from the English ones.
As a Polish person I have no problem saying that Marie Skłodowska-Curie was French, as she did have the citizenship and spent most of her life in France. But then again not mentioning her Polish heritage and (despite it being the international standard) only referring to her by "Curie", when she specifically kept her maiden name as a part of her new surname (a somehow common practice in Poland) doesn't sit right with me. We've had enough taken from us, let us enjoy the greatest scientific mind to come out of the country.
Furthermore I'd like to nitpick that Charlemagne and by extension Clovis were just as, or even more, German than they were French. But I guess both nations can somehow claim them.
An even bigger nitpick is that William the Conqueror was probably frenchified enough to call him that, though it also kind of simplifies his background.
Listing Clovis or Charlemagne as French is ridiculous. The notion of France or being French didn't even exist during their lifetime. The French are not the Franks, even if their name share the same origin. Yes, the Frankish kingdom(s)/empire covered large parts of modern France. But so did the Roman Empire with Italy, and being Roman is not the same as being Italian.
It's almost like saying William the Conqueror was a famous Englishman.
Quoting Wikipedia from the article "List of French Monarchs":
"Classical French historiography usually regards Clovis I, king of the Franks (r. 507–511), as the first king of France. However, most historians today consider that such a kingdom did not begin until the establishment of West Francia, after the fragmentation of the Carolingian Empire in the 9th century."
Can we all shut up about Marie Curie? She is here as the answer to a single question in a quiz on a trivia website. Nothing about that gets close to an international incident, yet people keep banging on as if they, their country, their national honour have been brutally assaulted... by a question in a quiz on a trivia website. Good grief.
A important author, one of my favourites as a kid, too but his legacy doesn't compare to that of other authors or philosophers, some of which were mentioned in this very quiz (Rousseau, Voltaire, Montesquieu, Victor Hugo, Proust, etc.)
Did he delete his account himself?
as Polish - American. Since she was in France instead, how about referring to her as Francolish or Polarance. Does that satisfy you ?
Fun fact: Curie was actually born in Russia as Poland had been partitioned into nonexistence.
http://www.jetpunk.com/user-quizzes/51892/famous-people-from-germany
Since Beckett was a protegee of James Joyce, we now have a direct line of mentorship from Joyce to Andre. I find that delightful.
Nevertheless, check put my "Famous Polish people" quiz: http://www.jetpunk.com/user-quizzes/97363/famous-poles
I didn't get Pasteur. He is mostly known for the discovery of the first vaccine against rabies. But then, I guess I didn't used my brain to wonder where does "pasteurization" comes from...
So funny to see people arguing about Marie Curie :D In France, we consider her Polish AND French.
More generally, thank you for the type-ins allowing the French spellings when they differ from the English ones.
This has been posted a million times. Everyone knows that Curie was born in Poland.
No one is disrespecting your country. Poland is great.
Furthermore I'd like to nitpick that Charlemagne and by extension Clovis were just as, or even more, German than they were French. But I guess both nations can somehow claim them.
An even bigger nitpick is that William the Conqueror was probably frenchified enough to call him that, though it also kind of simplifies his background.
She used both surnames after all
It's almost like saying William the Conqueror was a famous Englishman.
"Classical French historiography usually regards Clovis I, king of the Franks (r. 507–511), as the first king of France. However, most historians today consider that such a kingdom did not begin until the establishment of West Francia, after the fragmentation of the Carolingian Empire in the 9th century."
Nice quiz!
Thanks