MLB Toronto Blue Jays Best Players

Can you name the 24 best players to play for the Toronto Blue Jays franchise based on total bWAR accumulated for the team.
years and awards = during time with team not overall career
Pos. = Position played most during time with team
ROY = Rookie of the Year GG = Gold Glove, SS = Silver Slugger
Bolded = In the Hall of Fame
Quiz by
lhr131415
Rate:
Last updated: September 29, 2025
You have not attempted this quiz yet.
First submittedJuly 22, 2025
Times taken44
Average score54.2%
Report this quizReport
7:00
Enter answer here
0
 / 24 guessed
The quiz is paused. You have remaining.
Scoring
You scored / = %
This beats or equals % of test takers also scored 100%
The average score is
Your high score is
Your fastest time is
Keep scrolling down for answers and more stats ...
WAR
Years
Player
Pos.
Awards
56.8
1979 - 1992, 1998
Dave Stieb
P
 
48.0
1998 - 2009
Roy Halladay
P
2003 Cy Young
38.4
2008 - 2017
José Bautista
RF
3x SS
37.5
1983 - 1990, 1993, 1998 -1999, 2001
Tony Fernández
SS
4x GG
36.8
1993 - 2004
Carlos Delgado
1B
3x SS
29.6
1984 - 1992
Jimmy Key
P
 
29.5
1981 - 1989
Jesse Barfield
RF
2x GG, SS
28.7
1999 - 2010
Vernon Wells
CF
3x GG, SS
26.5
1991 - 1999
Pat Hentgen
P
1996 Cy Young
26.0
1980 - 1989
Lloyd Moseby
CF
SS
25.9
2019 - Active
Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
1B
GG, 2x SS
24.9
2006 - 2016
Edwin Encarnación
DH
 
24.8
1977 - 1988
Jim Clancy
P
 
22.6
1989 - 1996
John Olerud
1B
 
22.3
1991 - 1995
Devon White
CF
5x GG
22.3
1991 - 1995
Roberto Alomar
2B
5x GG, SS
21.2
1981 - 1990
George Bell
LF
2x SS, 1987 MVP
21.0
2001 - 2008
Juan Guzmán
P
 
20.9
2019 - Active
Bo Bichette
SS
 
20.4
2004 - 2009
Álex Ríos
RF
 
20.2
1997 - 1998
Roger Clemens
P
1997, 1998 Cy Young
19.8
2015 - 2018
Josh Donaldson
3B
2x SS, 2015 MVP
19.4
1986 - 1990
Fred McGriff
1B
SS
19.2
1977 - 1989
Ernie Whitt
C
 
Save Your Stats
Your Next Quiz
Can you name the ten Asian countries with the largest GDPs?
Click all the landlocked countries without clicking any countries which border the sea.
Uh oh, my literary character is happy, but that’s such a boring word! Help me by clicking only words that mean “happy”.
Drag the pin onto the correct country. Careful, though! Three wrong moves and the game ends.
Comments
No comments yet